TABLE 1. Summary of Transplantation Approaches.
Transplantation Approaches: |
Outcomes: | Representative References |
---|---|---|
Adrenal Medulla Transplants |
Cell survival poor, failed in blinded clinical trials | [27-30] |
Carotid Body Grafts | Minimal benefits in clinical trials | [31-37] |
Allogenic Human FVM Transplants |
Ethical concerns, failed in clinical trials despite several spectacular successes reported in open-label studies from several different centers, Lewy body like pathology in grafts, graft-induced dyskinesias in many patients |
[38-49] |
Porcine FVM Xenotransplants |
Need chronic immunosuppression, failed in clinical trial despite success in preclinical studies |
[50-59] |
hRPEC transplants | Post-natal hRPEC failed in placebo controlled clinical trials, but embryonic hRPEC were successfully engrafted in animal studies and effective in open-labeled clinical trials. No need for immunosuppression even in the case of embryonic hRPEC xenografts. However, limited autopsy report from post-natal hRPEC grafted patent showed poor cell survival and macrophage infiltration of graft sites. |
[60-71] |
hES Transplant | No clinical trial yet, cell death of transplanted cells reported even with immunosuppression |
[72-77] |
iPSC Transplant | No clinical trial yet, immunosuppression necessary to avoid cell death in grafts |
[17, 78-82] |