Table 1: Quality of Evidence of Included Studies*,†.
Study Design | Level of Evidence† |
Number of Eligible Studies |
---|---|---|
Large RCT, systematic review of RCTs | 1 | 5 |
Large RCT unpublished but reported to an international scientific meeting | 1(g)† | 0 |
Small RCT | 2 | 16 |
Small RCT unpublished but reported to an international scientific meeting | 2(g) | 0 |
Non-RCT with contemporaneous controls | 3a | 0 |
Non-RCT with historical controls | 3b | 0 |
Non-RCT presented at international conference | 3(g) | 0 |
Surveillance (database or register) | 4a | 0 |
Case series (multisite) | 4b | 0 |
Case series (single site) | 4c | 0 |
Retrospective review, modelling | 4d | 0 |
Case series presented at international conference | 4(g) | 0 |
Total | 21 |
g refers to grey literature; RCT, randomized controlled trial.
For each included study, levels of evidence were assigned according to a ranking system based on a hierarchy proposed by Goodman. (38) An additional designation “g” was added for preliminary reports of studies that have been presented at international scientific meetings.