Skip to main content
. 2009 Sep 1;9(5):1–51.

Table 1: Overview of systematic reviews investigating oral appliances for sleep apnea.

Systematic
review
Databases
searched (years)
Inclusion criteria Studies eligible for
inclusion
McDaid et al (NICE review), 2009 (1) Medline Embase Cochrane Up to November 2006
  • RCTs

  • Primary outcome: measures of sleepiness

29 studies (systematic review compares CPAP to other technologies; 6 RCTs comparing CPAP to MAS were identified)
Lim et al (Cochrane review), 2006 (2) updated to June 2007 Medline Cochrane Up to June 2007
  • RCTs

  • Patients with OSA (AHI >5)

  • >16 years

  • Primary outcome: daytime sleepiness

  • Secondary outcomes: quality of life, cognitive function, side effects, oxygen desaturation indices, 1-year mortality, patient preference

17 studies
Ferguson et al.
2006 (4)
PubMed Up to July 2004
  • Adult patients

  • English

  • Peer-reviewed

15 randomized trials
Hoekema et al.
2004 (5)
Medline
(1966-2002)
Embase
(1989-2002)
Cochrane
(1800-2002)
  • Patients with OSA (AHI >5)

  • >21 years

  • Intervention group treated with MRA

  • Control group treated with any conservative, surgical or non-invasive treatment (including no treatment or placebo)

  • Primary outcome AHI during a full-night sleep study*

16 (13 included in meta-analyses)
ECRI
2002 (3)
Medline
(up to Aug 2001)
Embase
(up to Aug 2001)
Cochrane
(up to Aug 2001)
ECRI databases
(up to Aug 2001)
  • Patients with OSA

  • Pre- and post-test studies

  • Parallel and single-arm trials

  • FDA approved devices

5 randomized trials

AHI, apnea hypopnea index; ESS, Epworth Sleepiness Scale; MAS, mandibular advancement splints