Skip to main content
. 2008 Oct 1;8(4):1–98.

Table 37: Overall Summary Statement of the Benefit and Risk for Patient-Directed Initiatives*.

Intervention Target Population 1° or 2° Prevention Overall Quality (GRADE) Benefits Risks/Burden Overall Strength of Recommendation (GRADE)
Physical exercise Seniors with mild to moderate dementia Moderate Improvement in functional, cognitive, and behavioural outcomes
  • Short-term follow-up and heterogeneity in studies

  • Unclear if leads to delayed institutionalization

Moderate
Physical exercise Seniors with good cognitive functioning (no dementia) High/Moderate Reduced risk of subsequent cognitive decline
  • Unknown if leads to delayed diagnosis of dementia or institutionalization

High/Moderate
Short-term Cognitive decline            
Short-term Incidence of dementia     High/Moderate Decreased incidence of dementia
  • Unknown if leads to delayed institutionalization

High/Moderate
Long-term Incidence of dementia     Moderate Decreased incidence of dementia
  • Unknown if leads to delayed institutionalization

Moderate
Nonpharmacologic and nonexercise interventions Seniors with mild to moderate dementia Very low None
  • Intervention not offer significant benefit (possible type 2 error)

  • Unclear if leads to delayed institutionalization

Very low
Cognitive training            
Cognitive stimulation therapy (CST)     Moderate/Low Increased cognition and quality of life
  • Unclear how CST compares with past

  • terminologies and methodologies

  • Short-term results

  • Role and extent of maintenance

  • Unclear how CST may impact functional dependence

  • Unclear if leads to delayed institutionalization

Low
Nonpharmacologic and nonexercise interventions Seniors with good cognitive functioning (no dementia) Low Cognitive improvements sustained after 5 years, but none of these improvements had effects beyond the specific cognitive domains of the intervention)
  • Results addressing functional outcomes unclear

  • Need more than 5-year follow-up

  • No evidence to determine if cognitive training leads to

    1. delayed diagnosis of dementia

    2. delayed institutionali zation.

Very low
*

1° indicates primary;2°, secondary; CST, cognitive stimulation therapy; IADL, instrumental activities of daily living; RCT, randomized controlled trial.