Table 3: GRADE Quality Assessment for CSII pumps vs. MDI on HbA1c Adults with Type 2 Diabetes.
Study | Design | Study Quality | Consistency | Directness | Other modifying factors | Overall quality of evidence |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Raskin 2003 |
RCT |
Serious limitations* MODERATE |
Consistent LOW |
Indirect† LOW |
||
Herman 2005 | RCT HIGH |
Not applicable | LOW |
Inadequate or unknown allocation concealment (all studies); Unblinded assessment (all studies) however lack of blinding due to the nature of the study; ITT not well explained in 1 of 2 studies
Indirect due to lack of generalizability of findings since participants varied with respect to prior treatment regimens and intensive SMBG suggests highly motivated populations used in trials.