Table 7: Existing Systematic Reviews on Patient-Directed Behavioural Techniques for the Treatment of Urinary Incontinence*.
| Systematic Review, Year | Intervention | Number of Studies Included in Review | Results and Conclusions | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wallace et al., 2004 Updated in 2006 Cochrane review (29) |
Bladder training | 12 studies; 8 studies provided usable data | Clear conclusions regarding the effectiveness of bladder training are difficult to make based on the limited evidence available. Compared with no bladder training, point estimates of effect favoured bladder training; however, CI were wide and no statistically significant differences were found. |
Not limited to seniors Only 2 of 12 studies where majority of population >65 y |
| Teunissen et al., 2004 (38) | Behavioural therapy and drug therapy in community-based seniors | 4 before-after studies 4 RCTs | Behaviour therapy, including PFMT, is effective in reducing urinary leakage (5 studies). Behaviour therapy appears more effective than drug therapy in seniors (3 studies). There is insufficient high-quality evidence to make conclusions regarding drug therapy in seniors. |
Not limited to RCT evidence |
| Choi et al., 2007 (30) | PFMT versus no treatment | 12 studies | Studies heterogeneous in terms of types of incontinence, eligible ages, duration of PFMT. PFMT is effective in reducing
|
Only 5 of 12 studies where majority of population >65 y Included studies with multicomponent behavioural interventions and not just PFMT alone |
| Hay-Smith et al., 2006 Cochrane review (31) |
PFMT alone versus no treatment | 13 studies; 6 studies contributed data to the analysis | Considerable variation among studies in inclusion criteria, interventions and outcome measures
|
Excluded trials where PFMT was combined with another conservative therapy (to be examined in future reviews) Only 3 of 13 studies where majority of population >65 y Did not pool estimates of effect |
CI refers to confidence interval(s); MWES, mean weighted effect size; NS, not significant; PFMT, pelvic floor muscle training; RCT, randomized controlled trial; UI, urinary incontinence.