Skip to main content
. 2008 Oct 1;8(3):1–52.

Table 11: Studies with Interventions for Urinary Incontinence Led by Nurse Continence Advisors *.

Study,
Year

Location
Intervention Study
Design
Methods
Population
Outcome Results Limitations
Borrie et al., 2002 (51)

Ontario, Canada
NCA RCT NCA sessions every 4 weeks for 6 months versus usual primary care

421 men and women, 50% of participants > 65 y
Incontinent episodes and pad use Treatment group reported significantly fewer incontinent episodes (P = .001) and less pad usage (P = .021) than control group Allocation concealment not adequate, no justification for sample size

Potential for selection bias since subjects responded to active advertising
Moore et al., 2003

Australia (52)
NCA RCT NCA sessions weekly for 12 weeks versus outpatient urogynecology regimen (tertiary unit)

145 women, mean age 60 y
Incontinent episodes and pad use No significant differences between groups, but changes from baseline showed highly significant reduction of incontinence (incontinent episodes, pad use) for both treatment regimens (P < .01).

Caution – study not designed for an intragroup comparison Caution – comparison group not usual primary care

NCA regimen was less expensive than the standard urogynecology regimen (median difference A$87.30)
Allocation concealment not adequate, caution by authors of a high drop-out rate (24%)
Williams et al., 2005 (53)

United Kingdom
Specially trained nurses RCT Continence service by specially trained nurses for 4 weeks over 8-week treatment period versus standard primary care

3,746 men and women, 53% of participants > 60 y
Urinary symptoms Treatment group reported significantly less leakage (P = .002) and a greater overall improvement (at least 1 symptom alleviated) than control group (P < .001)

Cost-effectiveness analysis indicated that a nurse-led intervention could alleviate symptoms at a cost of £242 per symptom over a 3-month period
Unclear if this represents value for money
Note that randomization was carried out by household, at a ratio of 4:1 in favour of the continence nurse
*

NCA refers to nurse continence advisor; RCT, randomized controlled trial.