Table 11: Studies with Interventions for Urinary Incontinence Led by Nurse Continence Advisors *.
| Study, Year Location |
Intervention | Study Design |
Methods Population |
Outcome | Results | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Borrie et al., 2002 (51) Ontario, Canada |
NCA | RCT | NCA sessions every 4 weeks for 6 months versus usual primary care 421 men and women, 50% of participants > 65 y |
Incontinent episodes and pad use | Treatment group reported significantly fewer incontinent episodes (P = .001) and less pad usage (P = .021) than control group | Allocation concealment not adequate, no justification for sample size Potential for selection bias since subjects responded to active advertising |
| Moore et al., 2003 Australia (52) |
NCA | RCT | NCA sessions weekly for 12 weeks versus outpatient urogynecology regimen (tertiary unit) 145 women, mean age 60 y |
Incontinent episodes and pad use | No significant differences between groups, but changes from baseline showed highly significant reduction of incontinence (incontinent episodes, pad use) for both treatment regimens (P < .01). Caution – study not designed for an intragroup comparison Caution – comparison group not usual primary care NCA regimen was less expensive than the standard urogynecology regimen (median difference A$87.30) |
Allocation concealment not adequate, caution by authors of a high drop-out rate (24%) |
| Williams et al., 2005 (53) United Kingdom |
Specially trained nurses | RCT | Continence service by specially trained nurses for 4 weeks over 8-week treatment period versus standard primary care 3,746 men and women, 53% of participants > 60 y |
Urinary symptoms | Treatment group reported significantly less leakage (P = .002) and a greater overall improvement (at least 1 symptom alleviated) than control group (P < .001) Cost-effectiveness analysis indicated that a nurse-led intervention could alleviate symptoms at a cost of £242 per symptom over a 3-month period Unclear if this represents value for money |
Note that randomization was carried out by household, at a ratio of 4:1 in favour of the continence nurse |
NCA refers to nurse continence advisor; RCT, randomized controlled trial.