Skip to main content
. 2010 Apr 1;10(6):1–92.

Table 2: Systematic Reviews on Endovascular Laser Treatment of VV.

Author Year Search Period Review Objective Evidence
HTA Reports - Endovascular Laser Treatment (ELT) of VV
MAS-HTA 2009 2007 – Aug 2009
  • Systematic review of evidence of the safety, effectiveness, durability and cost effectiveness of ELT for VV to support public financing decisions

Reports (3 HTA, 12 SR, 13 RCT, 3 CCT, 28 CS)
CADTH 2009 2004 – May 2009
  • To review the clinical and cost effectiveness of ELT for VV

Reports (1 HTA, 4SR, 1RCT, 1 CCT, 2 CE, 2 costing)
MSAC 2008 Jan 1997 – Aug 2007 (surgery) Sep 2003 – Aug 2007 (laser)
  • Systematic review of available evidence on ELT for VV to support public financing decisions

Safety [ELT 40 reports and surgery 22 reports (sample > 100)] Effectiveness: 1 SR, 2 RCT,3 CCT
NICE (Rapid Review) 2003 To Feb 2003
  • Evaluate the safety and effectiveness of ELT of the long saphenous vein

5 case series
Systematic Reviews – Endovascular Laser Treatment of VV
Darwood et al. (41) 2009 1950 – Dec 2008
  • To identify original reports and RCT studies reporting outcomes for ELT

98 original studies (5 RCT)
Hoggan et al. (49) 2009 1997 – Aug 2007 (surgery) Sep 2003 - Aug 2007 (laser)
  • To compare the safety and effectiveness of ELT and surgery for VV

59 studies: 4 RCT, 3 CCT, 37CS, 15 different comparators
Van Den Bus et al. (58) 2009 Not stated
  • To inform clinicians about ELT and review the safety and effectiveness of ELT for varicose

237 reports (1 RCT)
Van Den Bus et al. (62) 2009 2007 – July 2008
  • To review common and rare complications associated with ELT

34 studies
Mundy et al. (50) 2005 Jan 1966 – Sep 2004
  • To assess the safety and effectiveness of ELT for VV

13 case series
Systematic Reviews – All Treatments for VV
Bacho et al. (63) 2009 Not Stated
  • To review the evidence regarding interventions (compression, sclerotherapy, surgery and endoluminal) for uncomplicated VV

ELT: 3 RCT, 1CCT, 3 case series
Leopardi et al. (55) 2009 Jan 1988 – Feb 2008
  • To review the safety and effectiveness of varicose vein treatments (conservative therapy, sclerotherapy, phlebectomy, ELT, radiofrequency ablation and surgery involving saphenous vein ligation and stripping) for

ALL: 4 SR, 10 RCT, 3 CCT
Van Den Bus et al. (58) 2009 To Feb 2007
  • Effectiveness of 4 therapies for lower extremity varicosities (foam sclerotherapy, ELT, radiofrequency, surgical ligation and stripping)

ELT: 30 case series
Badri et al. (54) 2008 Not stated
  • To compare safety and effectiveness of ELT, radiofrequency and sclerotherapy to surgery (ligation and vein stripping) for VV

ELT: 3 RCT, 10 case series
Luebke et al. (56) 2008 1970 – 2007
  • To assess the safety/effectiveness of endoluminal therapies (ELT, RF ablation, foam sclerotherapy) compared to conventional surgery

ELT: 3 RCT, 29 case series
Subramonia et al. (57) 2007 To 2005
  • To review the evidence for new endoluminal interventions for lower limb varicoses

ELT: 11 case series

CADTH, refers to the Canadian Agency for Drugs and Technology in Health Care; MSAC, Medical Services Advisory Committee; NICE, National Institute for Clinical Excellence; CCT, Controlled clinical trial; CE, Cost effectiveness; CS, Cohort series; ELT, Endovascular laser treatment; HTA, Health technology assessment; SR, Systematic review