Skip to main content
. 2006 Nov 1;6(20):1–180.
Study Design Population Prevalent fractures Incident fractures
Klotzbuecher et al., 2000 (94) Meta-analysis 33 studies 1996–1999 peri/postmenopausalwomen Wrist, vertebral, hip, pooled Vertebral, hip, wrist, pooled
Kanis et al., 2004 (95) Meta-analysis(11 large population–based studies 1994–2003 15,259 men and 44,902 women Prior fractures Hip, any fracture, osteoporotic fracture (with and without effect of BMD)
Haentjens et al., 2003 (96) Meta-analysis of 9 cohort studies 1982–2001 Colle’s fractures & spine fractures Hip fractures
Johnell et al., 2004 (98)
Immediately following fracture
Prospective longitudinal cohort study in Sweden 5-year follow-up 1,918 men and women identified by radiology to have a fracture at the spine, hip or shoulder Spine
Hip
Shoulder
Relative risk of Hip, spine, and forearm over time stratified by age 60 & age 80 years
Papaioannou et al., 2005 (19)
(Post-menopausal women)
Prospective multi-site population based Canadian cohort study 3-year follow-up 5,143 postmenopausal women who participated in the Canadian multicenter Osteoporosis Study mean age of group 66.4 (SD 9.6) –74.4 (SD 10.0) years Vertebral Forearm Nonvertebral Vertebral
Main nonvertebral (wrist, hip, humerus, pelvis or rib)
Any nonvertebral fractures
Bensen et al., 2005 (26) (Canada) Analysis of prospective multisite Canadian CANDOO database 3,426 postmenopausal women registered in the CANDOO Previous fractures after age 50 years OR for vertebral fractures, hip fractures, wrist fracture, & rib fracture
Schousboe et al., 2005 (102) Study of Osteoporotic Fractures (SOF) - Prospective cohort study in the US Mean follow-up 3.7 years 9,704 elderly community dwelling women, mean age 73.2 years (with wrist fracture) & 71.5 (no wrist fractures) Previous wrist fractures since age 50 years Hip fractures
Radiographic vertebral fracture
Van der Klift et al., 2004 (103) Prospective population-based cohort study – Part of the Rotterdam Study Mean follow-up 6.3 years 4,216 men & women (2467 women) age>55 years mean age for subgroups 65.2– 68.6 years Vertebral fracture Vertebral fracture
Porthouse et al., 2004 (104) UK comprehensive cohort study with anested randomized controlled trial on hipprotectors 2 year follow-up 4,292 women ≥ 70 years
Mean age 76.9
years
Previous fracture Hip, nonvertebral, wrist fractures
Taylor et al., 2004 (24) Study of Osteoporotic Fractures (SOF) - Prospective cohort study in the US 6,787 community-dwelling, ambulatory Caucasian women ≥age 65 (mean age 73.3 (SD 4.9) years from SOF with complete data Any previous fractures since age 50 years Hip fractures
Colon-Emeric et al., 2003 (105) Analysis of data from the Baltimore Hip Studies and the Established Populations for Epidemiologic Studies of the Elderly (EPESE)
Mean follow-up 6.0 and 1.6 years respectively
Baltimore study: 549 men & women >/= 65 years of age with acute hip fracture (Mean age 80.9 (SD 7.4) years EPESE: 10,680 community-dwelling men & women age >/= 65 years. Mean age 73.8 (SD 6.7) years Hip fracture Hazard ratio for subsequent nonhip skeletal fracture
Naves et al., 2003
(106)
(Longitudinal)
Prospective cohort study – Spanish cohort of the EVOS study
Follow-up 8 years
316 women and 308 men age> 50 years randomly selected from the EVOS cohort.
Mean age 65 (SD 9) for men and women
Prevalent vertebral fracture Prevalent and Incident vertebral fracture
Intraobserver agreement = 92%, interobserver agreement of 90%
Hip, Colles’, vertebral
Hip, Colles’
Albrand et al., 2003 (OFELY)
(25)
Healthypostmenopausalwomen
Longitudinal cohort study of healthy ambulatory Caucasian volunteers in Rhone district of France, followed for a mean of 5.3+1.1 years 672 postmenopausal healthy ambulatory Caucasian women (mean age 59.1 years (SD 9.8 years) All prevalent fractures after age 45 years Fragility fractures
Pongchaiyakul et al., 2005 (99) Part of ongoing Dubbo Osteoporosis Epidemiology study (DOES) – longitudinal, population-based study of risk factors for fracture & mortality in Australia (5 year follow-up) 114 men and 186 women (age> 60 years & free of illnesses that affect bone metabolism) randomly selected from the DOES database Mean age 69.8 years with vertebral deformity) & 69.4 years with no vertebral deformity Asymptomatic vertebral deformity (at least –3SD in vertebral height) confirmed on radiograph Any fracture
Hip fracture Vertebral fracture Colles’ fracture Major fractures (major upper or lower limb and/or rib fractures)
Hasseius et al., 2003 EVOS (101) Longitudinal European Vertebral Osteoporosis Study – multicenter study to evaluate vertebral deformity – men and women followed for 10 years Men & women age 50–80 years
213 men (mean age 63 years) and 257 women (mean age 64 years)
Vertebral deformity (–3 SD or –5 SD in vertebral height Any incident fracture
Any fragility fracture
Szulc et al., 2005 (97) A prospective study of osteoporosis and of its determinants in men (MINOS) in France Follow-up 7.5 years 791 men aged 51-85 years were followed prospectively for BMD and fractures Prevalent fractures Fractures
Total hip fractures