Study | Design | Population | Prevalent fractures | Incident fractures |
---|---|---|---|---|
Klotzbuecher et al., 2000 (94) | Meta-analysis 33 studies 1996–1999 | peri/postmenopausalwomen | Wrist, vertebral, hip, pooled | Vertebral, hip, wrist, pooled |
Kanis et al., 2004 (95) | Meta-analysis(11 large population–based studies 1994–2003 | 15,259 men and 44,902 women | Prior fractures | Hip, any fracture, osteoporotic fracture (with and without effect of BMD) |
Haentjens et al., 2003 (96) | Meta-analysis of 9 cohort studies 1982–2001 | Colle’s fractures & spine fractures | Hip fractures | |
Johnell et al., 2004 (98) Immediately following fracture |
Prospective longitudinal cohort study in Sweden 5-year follow-up | 1,918 men and women identified by radiology to have a fracture at the spine, hip or shoulder | Spine Hip Shoulder |
Relative risk of Hip, spine, and forearm over time stratified by age 60 & age 80 years |
Papaioannou et al., 2005 (19) (Post-menopausal women) |
Prospective multi-site population based Canadian cohort study 3-year follow-up | 5,143 postmenopausal women who participated in the Canadian multicenter Osteoporosis Study mean age of group 66.4 (SD 9.6) –74.4 (SD 10.0) years | Vertebral Forearm Nonvertebral | Vertebral Main nonvertebral (wrist, hip, humerus, pelvis or rib) Any nonvertebral fractures |
Bensen et al., 2005 (26) (Canada) | Analysis of prospective multisite Canadian CANDOO database | 3,426 postmenopausal women registered in the CANDOO | Previous fractures after age 50 years | OR for vertebral fractures, hip fractures, wrist fracture, & rib fracture |
Schousboe et al., 2005 (102) | Study of Osteoporotic Fractures (SOF) - Prospective cohort study in the US Mean follow-up 3.7 years | 9,704 elderly community dwelling women, mean age 73.2 years (with wrist fracture) & 71.5 (no wrist fractures) | Previous wrist fractures since age 50 years | Hip fractures Radiographic vertebral fracture |
Van der Klift et al., 2004 (103) | Prospective population-based cohort study – Part of the Rotterdam Study Mean follow-up 6.3 years | 4,216 men & women (2467 women) age>55 years mean age for subgroups 65.2– 68.6 years | Vertebral fracture | Vertebral fracture |
Porthouse et al., 2004 (104) | UK comprehensive cohort study with anested randomized controlled trial on hipprotectors 2 year follow-up | 4,292 women ≥ 70 years Mean age 76.9 years |
Previous fracture | Hip, nonvertebral, wrist fractures |
Taylor et al., 2004 (24) | Study of Osteoporotic Fractures (SOF) - Prospective cohort study in the US | 6,787 community-dwelling, ambulatory Caucasian women ≥age 65 (mean age 73.3 (SD 4.9) years from SOF with complete data | Any previous fractures since age 50 years | Hip fractures |
Colon-Emeric et al., 2003 (105) | Analysis of data from the Baltimore Hip Studies and the Established Populations for Epidemiologic Studies of the Elderly (EPESE) Mean follow-up 6.0 and 1.6 years respectively |
Baltimore study: 549 men & women >/= 65 years of age with acute hip fracture (Mean age 80.9 (SD 7.4) years EPESE: 10,680 community-dwelling men & women age >/= 65 years. Mean age 73.8 (SD 6.7) years | Hip fracture | Hazard ratio for subsequent nonhip skeletal fracture |
Naves et al., 2003 (106) (Longitudinal) |
Prospective cohort study – Spanish cohort of the EVOS study Follow-up 8 years |
316 women and 308 men age> 50 years randomly selected from the EVOS cohort. Mean age 65 (SD 9) for men and women |
Prevalent vertebral fracture Prevalent and Incident vertebral fracture Intraobserver agreement = 92%, interobserver agreement of 90% |
Hip, Colles’, vertebral Hip, Colles’ |
Albrand et al., 2003 (OFELY) (25) Healthypostmenopausalwomen |
Longitudinal cohort study of healthy ambulatory Caucasian volunteers in Rhone district of France, followed for a mean of 5.3+1.1 years | 672 postmenopausal healthy ambulatory Caucasian women (mean age 59.1 years (SD 9.8 years) | All prevalent fractures after age 45 years | Fragility fractures |
Pongchaiyakul et al., 2005 (99) | Part of ongoing Dubbo Osteoporosis Epidemiology study (DOES) – longitudinal, population-based study of risk factors for fracture & mortality in Australia (5 year follow-up) | 114 men and 186 women (age> 60 years & free of illnesses that affect bone metabolism) randomly selected from the DOES database Mean age 69.8 years with vertebral deformity) & 69.4 years with no vertebral deformity | Asymptomatic vertebral deformity (at least –3SD in vertebral height) confirmed on radiograph | Any fracture Hip fracture Vertebral fracture Colles’ fracture Major fractures (major upper or lower limb and/or rib fractures) |
Hasseius et al., 2003 EVOS (101) Longitudinal | European Vertebral Osteoporosis Study – multicenter study to evaluate vertebral deformity – men and women followed for 10 years | Men & women age 50–80 years 213 men (mean age 63 years) and 257 women (mean age 64 years) |
Vertebral deformity (–3 SD or –5 SD in vertebral height | Any incident fracture Any fragility fracture |
Szulc et al., 2005 (97) | A prospective study of osteoporosis and of its determinants in men (MINOS) in France Follow-up 7.5 years | 791 men aged 51-85 years were followed prospectively for BMD and fractures | Prevalent fractures | Fractures Total hip fractures |