Table 4: GRADE Quality of Studies.
Outcome | Design | Quality | Consistency | Directness | Overall Quality |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Angina | 1 RCT |
Poor Unclear dropouts Subanalyses Patients/providers not blinded Greater adverse effects in EECP group. |
Exercise duration not significantly different between arms. Authors’ results and conclusions not match. | Not all patients have severe, refractory stable
angina. Large exclusion criteria. |
Very Low |
Case series Registry studies |
Uncontrolled. | Concomitant therapy in patients. Dropouts not accounted for. |
Rationale for treatment unclear in some studies – e.g., patient “tune ups”. | ||
Heart Failure | 1 unpublished RCT (PEECH) |
Poor Unclear dropouts Subanalyses Patients/providers not blinded |
Conflicting co-primary endpoint
results. Exacerbation of HF in some patients. |
Large exclusion criteria. | Very Low |
Case series Registry studies |
Uncontrolled. | Concomitant therapy in patients. Dropouts not accounted for. |
Registry studies have patients enrolled for angina, not HF. |