Skip to main content
. 2006 Jun 15;12(Suppl 1):77–85. doi: 10.1177/15910199060120S111

Table 1.

Advantages and disadvantages associated with clipping and coil embolization.

Advantages Disdvantages

clipping Surgery is superior to intravascular
therapy because:
Surgery is inferior to intravascular
therapy because:
1. Long-term therapeutic effects are clear 1. General anesthesia is required
2. Accompanying lesions can be treated
at the same time
2. Conserving perforators near an aneurysm is
occasionally difficult
3. Vascular anatomy can be accurately
ascertained macroscopically
3. Cerebral compression is required
4. Intraoperative bleeding can be
effectively dealt with
4. Blocking circulation may be necessary
5. Skills differ between surgeons and institutions

embolization Intravascular therapy is superior to
surgery because:
Intravascular therapy is inferior to
surgery because:
1. General anesthesia is unnecessary (?) 1. Additional angiographies may be needed
within a short period of time
2. Systemic complications are not an issue 2. Long-term prognosis is unknown
3. Perforators near an aneurysm can be
conserved
3. Embolization may not be possible
depending on shape, size or location
4. Brain compression is unnecessary 4. A risk of cerebral infarction or parent vessel
occlusion is present
5. Cost is less than surgery (?) 5. Dealing with intraoperative bleeding is difficult
6. Skills differ between surgeons and institutions