TABLE 2.
TREATMENT TYPE | MECHANISM OF ACTION | ADMINISTERED BY | PREGNANCY SAFETY | LEVEL OF EVIDENCE | CLEARANCE % | RECURRENCE % | COMMENTS |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
TOPICAL | |||||||
Podophyllotoxin | Anti-wart lignans | Patient | Unknown | A | 45-7734,36 | 38-6538 | Cost-effective home treatment |
Imiquimod 5% cream | Induces secretion of cytokines that reduce HPV DNA viral load | Patient | Unknown | A | 5645 | 1345 | Lengthy duration and sporadic dosing frequency can affect compliance |
Imiquimod 3.75% cream | Induces secretion of cytokines that reduce HPV DNA viral load | Patient | Unknown | A | 28-3348 | 1548 | New formulation with more intuitive dosing regimen |
Sinecatechins 15% ointment | Possess antitumor, antiviral, antioxidant effects | Patient | Unknown | A | 5855 | 6-955 | Can often take 16 weeks to elicit positive response |
Podophyllin | Anti-wart lignans | Patient | No | C | 42-5067 | 46-6058 | Not generally recommended for EGW treatment |
5-FU | Inhibits key enzyme in DNA replication | Physician | No | C | 10-5048 | 5048 | Sometimes used for urethral warts |
DESTRUCTIVE AND SURGICAL | |||||||
TCA | Chemically destructive acids | Physician | Yes | B | 7049 | 18 50,51 | High clearance rates with relatively low morbidity |
Cryotherapy | Dermal damage induced by cold temps initiate immune response | Physician | Yes | B | 79-8812 | 25-4012 | Treated areas can take several weeks to heal, requires multiple treatments |
Electrosurgery | Thermal coagulation | Physician | Yes | B | 9458 | 2258 | Long-term effectiveness comparable to cryotherapy |
Scissor excision | Physical removal of diseased tissue | Physician | Yes | B | 7260 | 19-2960 | Outdated treatment modality, utilized with large lesions causing obstruction |
CO2 laser | Infrared light energy vaporizes lesions | Physician | Yes | B | 23-5212 | 60-7712 | Treatment of choice in immunocompromised |
SYSTEMIC | |||||||
Interferon | Interferes with viral replication | Physician | No | C | 17-6756,57,58 | 9-6956,57,58 | Topical use has higher clearance rates versus placebo; systemic use has comparable clearance rates versus placebo |
HPV=human papillomavirus, BCA=bichloroacetic acid, TCA=trichloroactetic acid; A=one double-blind, randomized, controlled trial; B=well-conducted clinical studies, no randomized, controlled trial; C=Evidence from expert committee reports/options and/or clinical experience of respected authorities, indicated absence of directly applicable studies of good quality