Table 4. Diagnostic value of Cough ≥2 weeks, any symptom, and CXR.
Screening strategy (strategy # as in Table 1 ) | TB cases with positive screen | Participants without TB with positive screen | Sensitivity(%) (95%CI*) | Specificity(%) (95%CI) | PPV(%) (95%CI) | AUC† |
Total N | 123 | 20,443 | ||||
1. Cough ≥2 weeks§ | 64 | 2,200 | 52 (41–63) | 89 (88–90) | 2.8 (2.0–3.2) | 0.71 |
in HIV-positive | 36 | 69 (56–83) | ||||
in HIV-negative | 20 | 41 (25–57) | ||||
in HIV-unknown | 8 | 36 (17–59) | ||||
2. Any symptom of any duration or severity§ | 111 | 13,878 | 90 (84–95) | 32 (30–34) | 0.8 (0.6–1.0) | 0.61 |
in HIV-positive | 50 | 96 (87–100) | ||||
in HIV-negative | 40 | 82 (68–91) | ||||
in HIV-unknown | 21 | 95 (77–100) | ||||
8. CXR – any abnormality** | 113 | 5,229 | 94 (88–98) | 73 (68–77) | 2.1 (1.5–2.7) | 0.83 |
in HIV-positive | 47 | 92 (81–98) | ||||
in HIV-negative | 48 | 100 (93–100) | ||||
in HIV-unknown | 18 | 86 (68–100) | ||||
11. Cough ≥2 weeks or any CXR abnormality§ | 119 | 8,702 | 97 (92–99) | 57 (55–60) | 1.4 (1.1–1.7) | 0.79 |
in HIV-positive | 52 | 100 (93–100) | ||||
in HIV-negative | 49 | 100 (93–100) | ||||
in HIV-unknown | 18 | 82 (60–95) |
CI = Confidence Interval CXR = Chest radiograph.
Where the design effect was ≤1 CI’s were not adjusted for cluster design but binomial exact CI presented.
AUC = Area under the receiver operating characteristic curve.
Denominator for HIV-positive n = 52, HIV-negative n = 49, HIV-unknown n = 48.
3 cases did not have a CXR, 1HIV+, 1HIV-, 1HIVunknown, so denominators are 120, 51, 48 and 21 respectively. For specificity: 1347 missing records.