Table 3.
Time/TX Condition | CD4 Count | SCL-90R | MSCL | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
M (SD) | a M Δ | d | M (SD) | a M Δ | d | M (SD) | a M Δ | d | |
Pre-test | |||||||||
MBSR | 479.05 (180.88) | 109.32 (64.81) | 24.92 (16.75) | ||||||
ESC | 579.67 (188.67) | 109.23 (59.16) | 25.58 (14.49) | ||||||
Post-test | |||||||||
MBSR | 504.48 (186.45) | +25.44*** | .62 | 97.46 (60.68) | −11.86*** | −1.34 | 18.49 (13.85) | −6.42*** | −1.26 |
ESC | 582.20 (189.72) | +2.52 | .08 | 109.38 (59.12) | +0.15 | <.01 | 25.73 (14.59) | +0.15 | .07 |
Diff. in d | .54 | 1.34 | 1.33 | ||||||
3-month | |||||||||
MBSR | 503.71 (182.07) | +24.66*** | .65 | 101.74 (60.84) | −7.58*** | −.85 | 18.91 (13.82) | −6.01*** | −1.16 |
ESC | 579.33 (188.57) | −0.35 | −.01 | 109.44 (60.14) | +0.21 | .02 | 25.69 (14.61) | +0.11 | .09 |
Diff. in d | .66 | .87 | 1.25 | ||||||
6-month | |||||||||
MBSR | 499.56 (183.47) | +20.52*** | .54 | 106.32 (61.77) | −3.00** | −.35 | 18.88 (13.75) | −6.04*** | −1.15 |
ESC | 579.00 (188.64) | −0.67 | −.02 | 109.70 (60.76) | +0.47 | .02 | 25.72 (14.63) | +0.14 | .06 |
Diff. in d | .56 | .37 | 1.21 | ||||||
9-month | |||||||||
MBSR | 487.09 (183.62) | +8.05* | .29 | 110.68 (62.46) | +1.36 | .16 | 19.54 (14.21) | −5.38*** | −1.10 |
ESC | 581.10 (187.12) | +1.43 | .03 | 110.10 (59.71) | +0.87 | .04 | 25.73 (14.63) | −0.15 | −.02 |
Diff. in d | .26 | .12 | 1.08 | ||||||
12-month | |||||||||
MBSR | 478.25 (182.93) | −0.80 | −.10 | 116.11 (64.13) | +6.79*** | .79 | 19.82 (14.37) | −5.09*** | −1.09 |
ESC | 579.21 (186.79) | −0.47 | −.02 | 110.62 (60.15) | +1.39 | .05 | 25.62 (14.58) | −0.04 | −.01 |
Diff. in d | .08 | .74 | 1.08 |
Notes. d = Cohen’s d; MBSR = mindfulness-based stress reduction; ESC = education and support condition;
p < 0.001;
p < 0.01;
p < 0.05;
= difference between pre-test and follow-up period;
Paired sample t-test for differences between pretest mean score and each respective follow-up mean score;
Difference in d between treatment conditions