Table 1. Potential risks and benefits of synchronous versus staged resection.
Synchronous |
Staged |
|||
---|---|---|---|---|
Benefit | Risk | Benefit | Risk | |
Reduced complications due to single operation |
Increased infectious liver complications due to bacterial contamination from intestinal resection |
Increased morbidity associated with multiple procedures |
||
Reduced length of hospital stay |
Risk of complications from unresected primary |
Reduced complications from unresected primary |
Risk of hepatotoxicity from chemotherapy given between colorectal and hepatic resections |
|
Increased anastomotic complications due to impaired liver function |
||||
Extent of hepatic resection limited due to concomitant intestinal resection |
Larger hepatic resections may be performed without increased morbidity |
|||
No delay in initiating systemic treatment |
Chemotherapy-associated hepatotoxicity may limit extent of liver resection |
Risk of complications following colorectal resection may delay chemotherapy prior to liver resection |
||
Opportunity to observe tumor response to neoadjuvant chemotherapy | No opportunity to assess tumor response if resection precedes systemic therapy |