Table 3. Oncologic outcomes following synchronous and staged resections.
Study [Year] | N | Overall Survival (median months) | Disease-free Survival (median months) |
---|---|---|---|
Vogt [1991] |
Synch: 19 Staged: 17 |
Synch: 18 Staged: 31 |
Synch: 7 Staged: 19 |
Tanaka [2004] |
Synch: 39 Staged: 37 |
Synch: 1 year: 86% 3 year: 68% 5 year: 53% Staged: 1 year: 83% 3 year: 47% 5 year: 47% |
Synch: 1 year: 64% 3 year: 20% 5 year: 16% Staged: 1 year: 51% 3 year: 34.5% 5 year: 28% |
Thelen [2007] |
Synch: 40 Staged: 179 |
Synch: 1 year: 86% 5 year: 53% 10 year: 32% Staged: 1 year: 90% 5 year: 39% 10 year: 26% |
Site(s) of recurrence did not differ between Synch and Staged |
Moug [2010] |
Synch: 32 Staged: 32 |
Synch: 39 Staged: 42 |
Synch: 10 Staged: 14 |
Brouquet [2010] | Synch: 43 Staged: Colon-Liver: 72 Liver-Colon: 27 |
Synch: 95 5 year: 55% Staged: Colon-Liver: 55 5 year: 48% Liver-Colon: 50 5 year: 39% |
Synch: 11 5 year: 55% Staged: Colon-Liver: 11 5 year: 48% Liver-Colon: 11 5 year: 39% |
Synch: synchronous resection of colorectal primary and hepatic metastasis.