Table 1. The characters of the 27 eligible studies.
Authors | Year | Region | Ethnicity | Type of study | Sample size(case/control) | Main assessments | Parameter |
Wang L et al [12] | 2010 | China | East Asian | case-control | 430/468 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF, mortality and combined endpoint in2 years |
Paczkowska A et al [13] | 2009 | Poland | White | case-control | 97/105 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Woodiwiss AJ et al [14] | 2008 | South African | Black | case-control | 403/429 | Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Biolo A et al [15] | 2008 | Brazil | mixed | case-control | 201/141 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF, mortality in 39.8 months |
Yu WP et al [16] | 2006 | China | East Asian | case-control | 105/100 | Arg389Gly | risk of HF; ΔHR, ΔLVEF, ΔLVEDd, ΔLVESd with3 months β-blocker treatment |
Nonen S et al [17] | 2005 | Japan | East Asian | case-control | 91/119 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Covolo L et al [18] | 2004 | Italy | White | case-control | 256/230 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Magnusson Y et al [19] | 2005 | Sweden | White | case-control | 375/492 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF, mortality in 5 years |
Small KM et al [20] | 2002 | America | mixed | case-control | 159/189 | Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Iwai C et al [21] | 2002 | Japan | East Asian | case-control | 163/157 | Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Forleo C et al [22] | 2007 | Italy | White | case-control | 189/378 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Tesson F et al [23] | 1999 | France | White | case-control | 426/395 | Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Fragoso JM et al [24] | 2006 | Mexico | Mexican | case-control | 47/93 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Podlowski S et al [25] | 2000 | Germany | White | case-control | 37/40 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | risk of HF |
Metra M et al [26] | 2010 | Italy | White | prospective | 183 | Arg389Gly | ΔHR, ΔLVEF, ΔLVEDv, ΔLVESv with 6 monthsβ-blocker treatment |
Chen L et al [27] | 2007 | Australia | White | prospective and retrospective | 135 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | ΔLVEF, ΔLVEDd, ΔLVESd with 1 year β-blocker treatment |
Luo M et al [28] | 2007 | China | East Asian | prospective | 156 | Arg389Gly | ΔLVEF, ΔLVESd with 3 months β-blocker treatment |
Liggett SB et al [29] | 2006 | America | Mixed | prospective | 515 | Arg389Gly | ΔHR, ΔLVEF with β-blocker treatment, mortalityin 12 months |
Terra SG et al [29] | 2005 | America | Mixed | prospective | 54 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | ΔHR, ΔLVEF, ΔLVEDd, ΔLVESd with 3 monthsβ-blocker treatment |
de Groote P et al [31] | 2005 | France | White | prospective | 199 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | ΔHR, ΔLVEF with 3 months β-blocker treatment |
Mialet Perez J et al [32] | 2003 | America | NS | retrospective | 224 | Arg389Gly | ΔLVEF after 6 months β-blocker treatment |
Petersen M et al [32] | 2011 | Denmark | White | retrospective | 305 | Arg389Gly | mortality in 6.7 years |
Leineweber K et al [34] | 2010 | Germany | White | prospective | 226 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | mortality in 45 months |
Cresci S et al [35] | 2009 | America | Mixed | prospective | 1133 | Arg389Gly | mortality and combined endpoint in 6.5 years |
White HL et al [36] | 2003 | UK and Netherland | White | retrospective | 600 | Arg389Gly | combined endpoint in 12 months |
Forleo C et al [37] | 2004 | Italy | White | prospective | 171 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | combined endpoint in 33 months |
Shin J et al [38] | 2007 | America | Mixed | prospective | 227 | Ser49Gly, Arg389Gly | mortality and combined endpoint in 2.8 years |
HF, heart failure; LVEF, left ventricular ejection fraction; LVEDd/v, left ventricular end diastolic diameter/volume; LVESd/v, left ventricular end systolic diameter/volume; combined endpoint, including death, heart transplantation and hospitalization; NS, not stated.