Table 2.
Author | Method | Purpose | Sample Characteristics | Findings |
---|---|---|---|---|
Bowes et al 200935 | Qualitative study with in-depth interviews | To explore parents’ longer term experience of having a child with type 1 diabetes | N = 17 (10 mothers, 7 fathers) Child age: range 9–23 y T1DM duration: 7–10 y Wales, UK |
Diagnosis: Grief, some blamed themselves. Experience over time: Became accustomed to daily tasks and accepted routine as part of life. Never really accepted diagnosis. Recurring feelings of sadness. Felt “alone.” Stress: Practical management of diabetes was difficult. Knowledge of consequences. Constant worry. Transition to adolescence. Sources of support: Taking it in blocks of time. Support groups for some. |
Buckloh et al 200836 | Qualitative description with focus groups | To explore parents’ experience of learning about diabetes complications | N = 47 (30 mothers, 14 fathers, 3 other) Child age :13.2 y (2.5) T1DM duration: 4.5 y Diversity = 15% US |
Diagnosis: Emotional time with depression, sadness, anxiety. Overwhelmed. Focused on diabetes management. Experience over time: Adolescence difficulty and frustrating. Stress: Anxiety over long-term complications. Concerns over insurance, life span of child. Sources of support: Having optimism. |
Edmonds- Myles et al 201034 | Qualitative description | To explore psychosocial impact of T1DM in low-income families | N = 21 Child age: 10–18 y T1DM duration: 4.0–6.3 y Diversity: 66% US |
Experience over time: Began to adjust to diagnosis and T1DM care. Some felt that nothing was easier over time. Stress: Constant worry. Time-consuming regimen. Responsibility and hypervigilance. Financial pressures. Single parenthood. Sources of support: Professionals for white families. Friends and family for some. Faith. Humor. |
Faulkner 199637 | Descriptive with interviews | To explore how parents respond to school-age child with T1DM | N = 27 (from 7 families) Child age: 10.7 y T1DM duration: 4.6 y Diversity not reported US |
Diagnosis: Shock, anger, denial, fear of child death. Experience over time: Learning. T1DM care difficult at times. Began to share T1DM with child. Mothers mostly provided care. Stress: Insulin reactions. Worry about complications. Giving injections. Causing pain to child. Sources of support: Faith. Not allowing T1DM to consume life. |
Hatton et al 199532 | Qualitative interpretive (phenomenology) | To generate understanding of parents’ experience of infant or toddler with T1DM | N = 8 (2-parent families) Child age: 1.5 y T1DM: New to 2.5 y Canada |
Diagnosis: Horrifying experience. Fear of child death. Overwhelmed. Very emotional (shock, grief, sadness). Exhausted. Social isolation. Experience over time: Struggles with growing child and child need for independence. Challenge with school. Stress: Taking child home. Immense responsibility. Complex and all-pervading regimen. Inflicting pain on child. Unpredictable blood sugar. Sources of support: Professionals. Sharing responsibility with spouse. |
Lowes et al 200458 | Qualitative approach with in-depth interviews | To explore parents’ experience of having child with T1DM >1 y | N = 38 Child age: not reported New diagnosis Wales, UK |
Diagnosis: Shocked, distressed, overwhelmed. Experience over time: Routines established. Becoming more flexible. Promoting “normal life.” Continued sense of loss. Loss of spontaneity. Maintaining vigilance. Stress: Hypoglycemia. Inexplicable highs and lows. Constant worry. Sources of support: Professionals. Take it 1 day at a time. Other people with knowledge of T1DM. Optimism. |
Lowes et al 200531 | Qualitative longitudinal (Hermeneutics) | To explore parents’ experiences of child with T1DM >1 y | N = 38 Child age: not reported New diagnosis Wales, UK |
Diagnosis: Shocked, distressed, grief, fear, ill-prepared for situation. Experience over time: Still aware of losses (control, healthy child, etc). Feelings of sadness and guilt. More confident about T1DM care. Developing a routine. Stress: Constant worry. Constant planning around T1DM care. Sources of support: Optimism |
Marshall et al 200939 | Phenomenology | To explore parental experience of child with T1DM from diagnosis onward | N = 11 (10 mothers, 1 father) T1DM duration: 10 m to 8 y Some diversity, but statistics not reported UK |
Diagnosis: Grief, loss of healthy child, confidence Experience over time: Disruption in family patterns and parent–child relationship. Stress: Inflicting pain on child. Transition of T1DM care to child. |
Mellin et al 200459 | Content analysis | To explore parents’ perceptions of impact of T1DM on family | N = 30 (24 mothers, 6 fathers) Child age: 17.7 y (4.1) T1DM duration: 7.7 y (4.1) Diversity = 16% US |
Diagnosis: Huge emotional impact. Guilt. Experience over time: Organized home life around T1DM care Stress: Long-term complications. Constant burden and responsibility for diabetes care. Keeping blood sugar regulated. Change of own lifestyle. Sources of support: Maintaining positive attitude. |
Seppanen et al 199960 | Case study | To explore process of parental coping and experiences of social support | N = 2 (2-parent families) Child age: 3 and 4 y Newly diagnosed Finland |
Diagnosis: Guilt and lack of information. Disbelief. Highly motivated to learn care. Experience over time: Reorganized life. Felt alone in responsibility for child’s care. Stress: Injections. Very demanding regimen. Nighttime blood glucose. Focus on meals and eating. Child rebellion. Sources of support: Professionals. Relatives and friends. Emotional support from spouse and shared responsibility. Positive attitude. |
Smaldone et al 20115 | Content analysis | To explore perceptions of psychosocial adaptation in parenting young children with T1DM from diagnosis through childhood | N = 14 Child age: 11.1 y (3.5) T1DM duration: 8.0 y (3.7) Diversity US |
Diagnosis: Fear and doubt. Feeling totally overwhelmed. Experience over time: No parents felt they had achieved mastery (ongoing challenges, always changing). Tension between promoting normal development of child and keeping child safe. Stress: Complicated regimen. School experience. Child’s future. Sources of support: Availability of diabetes team. Sharing responsibility with spouse. Support groups for some. |
Sullivan- Bolyai 20032 | Qualitative description | To describe the day-to-day experiences of mothers of young children with T1DM | N = 28 Child age: 2.9 y (0.6) T1DM duration: 1.3 y (0.7) Diversity: 11% US |
Diagnosis: Hard to learn T1DM care. Experience over time: Rigid rules at first. More relaxed and confident over time. Modified T1DM care with change in developmental needs. Stress: Constant vigilance. Daily tasks. Fear of hypoglycemia. Nighttime and nap time. Day care issues. Concern about complications. Sources of support: Professional. Spouse. Family, friends. Support group for some. Patience. Inner strength. |
Sullivan- Bolyai 200633 | Qualitative description | To describe fathers’ experience of young child with T1DM | N = 14 Child age: 5.0 y (2.0) T1DM duration: 1.4 y (0.8) Diversity = 0% US |
Diagnosis: Shock. Traumatic experience. Quick move to action. Overwhelmed with care and what was needed to learn. Experience over time: Gaining confidence. Providing respite for spouse. Treating child “normally.” Enduring sadness. Stress: Injections and causing pain. Fear of giving too much insulin. Nighttime. Worry about complications and child in school. Sources of support: Professionals. Sharing responsibility with spouse. |
Wennick et al 200638 | Qualitative longitudinal (hermeneutics) | To understand family lived experience when child diagnosed with T1DM | N = 12 (2-parent families) Child age: 9.5 y Newly diagnosed Sweden |
Diagnosis: Sorrow and despair. Tearful. Powerlessness. Trying to make sense of diagnosis, reviewing symptoms. Experience over time: Reconstructing everyday life. Family life had to be carefully planned. Focus on blood sugar. Stress: Worry about complications and death. Complex T1DM care. Maintaining blood glucose. Nighttime. Child going to school or friends. |
Abbreviation: T1DM, type 1 diabetes mellitus.