Table 7.
Statistical Family | Variant | Uses | R command | SPSS command | Reference(s) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Kappa (two coders) | Cohen’s kappa | No bias or prevalence correction | cohen.kappa(…)$kappa.c (concord package) | None* | Cohen (1960) |
Siegel & Castellan’s kappa | Bias correction | cohen.kappa(…)$kappa.sc (concord package) | CROSSTABS \STATISTICS=KAPPA … | Siegel & Castellan (1988, pp. 284- 291) | |
Byrt et al’s kappa | Prevalence correction | cohen.kappa(…)$kappa.bbc (concord package) | None* | Byrt et al. (1993) | |
Cohen’s weighted kappa | Disagreements differentially penalized (e.g., with ordinal variables) | kappa2(…, weight = c(“equal”, “squared’)) (irr package) | None, but quadratic weighting is identical to a two-way mixed, single-measures, consistency ICC | Cohen (1968) | |
Kappa-like Pi-family statistics (three or more coders) | Fleiss’s kappa | Raters randomly sampled for each subject | kappam.fleiss(…) (irr package) | None* | Fleiss (1971); Gross (1986) |
Light’s kappa, | Average kappa across all rater pairs | kappam.light(…) (irr package) | None*, but two-rater kappa can be computed for each coder pair then averaged manually | Light (1971) | |
Davies & Fleiss’s kappa | Kappa-like coefficient across all rater pairs using average P(e) | None* | None* | Davies (1982) |
Note:
Macros and syntax files may be available for computing statistical variants that are not natively available in SPSS or the R concord or irr packages. The reader is referred to the SPSSX Discussion hosted by the University of Georgia (http://spssx-discussion.1045642.n5.nabble.com) as one example repository of unverified user-created macros and syntax files created for SPSS.