Skip to main content
. 2012 Jul 31;6(7):e1758. doi: 10.1371/journal.pntd.0001758

Table 3. Sensitivity, specificity, positive predictive value (PPV) and negative predictive value (NPV) of different tests for the diagnosis of S.mansoni.

Setting A Setting B Setting C All settings A-B-C
Sensitivity Specificity PPV NPV Sensitivity Specificity PPV NPV Sensitivity Specificity PPV NPV Sensitivity Specificity PPV NPV
% CI % CI % CI % CI % CI %CI % CI % CI % CI % CI % CI % CI % CI % CI % CI % CI
Nine Kato-Katz as ‘reference’ diagnostic test
Single Kato-Katz (stool day 1) 58 100 100 80.7 56.8 100 100 47.6 49.0 100 100 52.4 53.8 100 100 58.1
(44.3–71.7) / / (73.3–88.1) (49.5–64.1) / / (39.5–55.7) (41.2–56.9) / / 44.8–60.0) (48.8–58.8) / / (53.4–62.8)
Triplicate Kato-Katz (stool day 1) 66 100 100 83.8 68.2 100 100 55.2 69.7 100 100 64.9 68.5 100 100 67
(52.9–79.1) / / (76.8–90.9) (61.3–75.1) / / (46.5–63.9) (62.4–76.9) / / (56.8–73.0) (63.8–73.2) / / (62.2–71.9)
Triplicate CCA 92 54.5 53.5 92.3 90.9 34.8 78.0 60 96.1 69.0 71.3 81.8 93.2 40.6 71 79.2
(84.4–99.5) (44.1–64.9) (42.9–64.0) (85.1–99.6) (86.7–95.2) (23.5–46.0) (72.4–83.7) (44.8–75.2) (93.1–99.2) (59.2–78.7) (65.2–77.4) (68.7–95.0) (90.6–95.7) (34.4–46.7) (67.0–75.0) (72.1–86.3)
Single CCA (urine day 1) 82 64.7 56.9 86.4 82.4 62.3 84.8 58.1 87.7 42.5 78.6 72.5 84.5 61.5 77.4 71.8
(71.6–92.6) (54.8–74.8) (45.5–68.4) (78.1–94.6) (76.8–88.0) (50.9–73.8) (79.4–90.2) (46.9–69.3) (82.6–92.9) (32.1–52.9) (72.5–84.7) (61.9–83.0) (80.9–88.1) (55.4–67.6) (73.4–81.4) (65.7–77.9)
CCA-L 46 100 100 76.5 68.8 91.3 95.3 53.4 55.5 92.0 92.5 53.7 60.4 94.7 94.7 60.5
(32.2–59.8) / / (63.8–84.3) (61.9–75.6) (84.7–98.0) (91.6–99.0) (44.4–62.4) (47.7–63.3) (86.2–97.7) (87.1–97.8) (45.7–61.7) (55.5–65.3) (91.9–97.5) (91.8–97.5) (55.6–65.4)
Combined results as ‘reference’ diagnostic test
Single Kato-Katz (stool day 1) 32.2 100 100 44.0 45.2 100 100 16.6 35.3 100 100 16.3 39. 100 100 23.6
(22.6–41.9) / / (34.7–53.4) (38.7–51.8) / / (10.5–22.6) (29.0–41.7) / / (10.7–21.9) (34.8–43.1) / / (19.5–27.6)
Triplicate Kato-Katz (stool day 1) 36.7 100 100 45.7 45.3 100 100 19.2 50.2 100 100 20.1 49.7 100 100 27.2
(26.7–46.6) / / (36.2–55.2) (47.7–60.9) / / (12.3–26.1) (43.5–56.9) / / (13.4–26.9) (45.3–53.9) / / (22.6–31.8)
Single CCA (urine day 1) 80 100 100 92.3 77.4 100 100 60 80.5 100 100 81.8 79.1 100 100 79.2
(71.7–88.3) / / (85.1–99.6) (71.9–82.9) / / (44.8–75.2) (75.2–85.8) / / (68.7–95.0) (75.6–82.6) / / (72.1–86.3)
Triplicate CCA 95.6 100 100 72.7 92.8 100 100 32.4 97.2 100 100 39.1 95.1 100 100 47.4
(91.3–99.8) / / (62.0–83.5) (89.3–96.2) / / (21.8–43.1) (95.0–99.4) / / (27.6–50.6) (93.2–96.9) / / (40.6–54.1)
CCA-L 25.6 100 100 41.7 57.5 100 100 20.3 43.3 100 100 18.1 46.2 100 100 25.9
(16.5–34.6) / / (32.7–50.8) (50.9–64.0) / / (13.1–27.6) (36.6–49.9) / / (11.9–24.3) (41.9–50.5) / / (21.5–30.3)