Skip to main content
. 2012 Jul 16;14(4):e102. doi: 10.2196/jmir.1818

Table 4.

Mean differences in speech perception scores (D%) assessed with different voice over Internet protocol qualities (degree of packet loss) versus conventional telephone quality using the Hochmair-Schulz-Moser (HSM) Sentence Test.

Participant
group
SNR
(dB)a
Packet loss
None (0%) Mild (5%) Medium (10%) Severe (20%)
D% P value D% P value D% P value D% P value
CIb users 0 +2 NAc +1 NA +2 NA +2 NA
5 +21 .002d +11 .01d +9 .008d +1 .81
10 +36 .001d +34 .002d +30 .002d +4 .04e
15 +36 .001d +23 .01e +25 .006d +6 .25
Quiet +16 .001d +16 .002d +16 .002d –1 .92
HAf users 0 +4 .16 +2 .69 +0 >.99 –1 .02e
5 +18 .002d +4 .56 +6 .38 –6 .16
10 +16 .003d +9 .08 +4 .32 –12 .02e
15 +6 .004d –4 .65 –7 .25 –17 .004d
Quiet +2 .16 –1 .31 –1 .56 –7 .004d
NHAg 0 +53 .001d +46 .002d +33 .002d +22 .002d
5 +17 .003d +16 .002d +16 .004d –3 .49
10 +1 .21 +3 .06 +1 .47 –6 .009d
15 0 NA 0 NA –1 NA –1 >.99
Quiet 0 NA 0 NA –1 NA –1 NA

a Signal to noise ratio.

b Cochlear implant.

c Not applicable.

d Statistically significant with Bonferroni correction.

e Statistically significant without Bonferroni correction.

f Hearing aid.

g Normal-hearing adults.