Table 1.
Author | N (% female) | Recruitment source | Diagnostic/inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria | Tx conditions (duration and setting) | Primary outcome assessed | Secondary outcome assessed | Primary results | Secondary results |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Psychopharmacological Interventions | |||||||||
Antidepressants | |||||||||
Fluoxetine | |||||||||
Kaye et al.12 | 39 (100) | Inpatient ED Program responders | DSM-IV ANr | 52 weeks Outpatient 20 mg
|
Weight change for relapse prevention, YBOCS-EDS | HRSD, YBOCS, HARS | FLX had significant change in weight, Y-BOCS-ED from pre-post tx, PL did not greater tx completion for FLX vs. PL (63% vs. 16%) | FLX had significant change in HARS, HRSD from pre-post tx, PL did not | |
Walsh et al.15 | 93 (100) | Weight restored patients with AN | DSM-IV AN (w/o amenorrhea), 16–45 years old, BMI > 19 | 52 weeks Outpatient 20–80 mg
|
Time to relapse | FLX = PL | |||
Antipsychotics | |||||||||
Olanzapine | |||||||||
Mondraty et al.20 | 15 (–) | Inpatient psychiatric unit | DSM-IV AN | Inpatient
|
Anorectic rumination (Padua inventory), weight | OLZ > CPZ | |||
Brambilla et al.18 | 30 (100) | ED center referrals | DSM-IV AN >18 years old | Serious psychiatric or medical condition | 3 months Outpatient
|
BMI, EDI, YBC-EDS | HRSD, TCI, Buss-Durkee rating scale (aggression) | OLZ > PL on YBC-ED compulsions, on BMI for ANbp only | OLZ > PL on HRSD, TCI-persistence |
Bissada et al.17 | 34 (100) | ED tx center referrals | DSM-IV AN (w/o amenorrhea), BMI < 17.5 | Serious psychiatric or medical condition, suicidality, concurrent tx | 10 weeks Day hospital
|
BMI | PAI, YBOCS | OLZ > PL | OLZ > PL on YBOCS obsessions |
Attia et al.19 | 23 (96) | Community recruitment | DSM-IV AN w/o amenorrhea, >16 years old, 19 > BMI >14 | Severe medical or psychiatric problem | 8 weeks Outpatient
|
BMI, EDI, YCB-EDS, BSQ | BAI, BDI | OLZ > PL on BMI | OLZ = PL |
Psychosocial Interventions | |||||||||
Psychodynamic | |||||||||
Dare et al.26 | 84 (74) | Community referrals | DSM-IV AN, > 18 years old | Serious psychiatric or medical condition | 1 year Outpatient
|
M-R scales, weight | FOC, FT > TAU CAT = TAU on weight |
||
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy | |||||||||
Pike et al.30 | 33 (100) | Inpatient tx responders | DSM-IV ANr, 18–45 years old, >90% IBW | Severe comorbid psychopathology | 50 sessions Outpatient
|
Relapse rate, time to relapse, M-R scales | CBT > NUT | ||
McIntosh et al.33 | 56 (100) | Community referrals | DSM-IV AN, 17–40 years old, BMI < 19 | Severe psychiatric or medical condition | 20 sessions Outpatient
|
Global anorexia nervosa rating, BMI, weight, EDE, EDI | GAF | CBT = IPT CBT = NST On global rating CBT = NST > IPT on EDE restraint |
NST > IPT = CBT |
Interpersonal Psychotherapy | |||||||||
McIntosh et al.33 | 56 (100) | Community referrals | DSM-IV AN, 17–40 years old, BMI < 19 | Severe psychiatric or medical condition | 20 sessions Outpatient
|
Global anorexia nervosa rating, BMI, weight, EDE, EDI | GAF | CBT = IPT NST > IPT On global rating CBT = NST > IPT on EDE restraint |
NST > IPT = CBT |
Family Based Therapy | |||||||||
Eisler et al.40 | 40 (98) | Community referrals | DSM-IV or ICD-10 AN | Mean of 16 sessions (flexible dose) Outpatient
|
M-R scales, EDI, EAT | RSES, SMFQ, MOCI | SFT > CFT for families with high EE CFT > SFT on EDI | CFT > SFT on MOCI, SMFQ | |
Geist et al.131 | 61 (100) | Community referrals to specialist tx center | DSM-IV AN < 90% IBW, 12–17 years old | Suicide risk, serious psychiatric or medical condition | 8 sessions Outpatient
|
Weight, EDI | CDI, BSI, FAM-III | FT = FGP | FT = FGP |
Dare et al.26 | 84 (74) | Community referrals | DSM-IV AN, > 18 years old | Serious psychiatric or medical condition | 1 year Outpatient
|
M-R scales, weight | FOC, FT > TAU on weight | ||
Lock et al.39 | 86 (90) | Pediatric referrals | DSM-IV AN (≥1 menstrual cycle missed), 12–18 years old | Serious psychiatric or medical condition, additional tx | Outpatient
|
EDE, BMI, YBC-EDS | KSADS, CBCL, family functioning scale | STFT = LFT | STFT = LFT |
Lock et al.37 | 121 (91) | Community clinic referrals | DSM-IV AN w/o amenorrhea, 12–18 years old, living with family, IBW < 86% | Serious psychiatric or medical condition, previous FT, AFT tx | 24 sessions Outpatient
|
Remission rate, BMI percentile | FT = AFT on remission rate FT > AFT on BMI At follow-up: FT > AFT on remission rate FT = AFT on BMI |
||
Psychopharmacological + Psychosocial Interventions | |||||||||
Walsh et al.15 | 93 (100) | Weight restored patients with AN | DSM-IV AN (w/o amenorrhea) 16–45 years old, BMI > 19 | 52 weeks Outpatient 20–80 mg
|
Time to relapse | FLX + CBT = PL + CBT | |||
Brambilla et al.18 | 30 (100) | ED center referrals | DSM-IV AN >18 years old | Serious psychiatric or medical condition | 3 months Outpatient
|
BMI, EDI, YBC-EDS | HRSD, TCI, Buss-Durkee rating scale (aggression) | CBT + OLZ > CBT + PL on eating disorder compulsions, on BMI for ANbp only | CBT + OLZ > CBT+ PL HRSD, TCI-persistence |
Note: Greater than symbol (>) refers to significantly better outcome.
Abbreviations: AFT, Adolescent Focused Therapy; AN, Anorexia Nervosa; BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; BED, Binge Eating Disorder; BMI, Body Mass Index; BN, Bulimia Nervosa; BSI, Brief Symptom Inventory; CBCL, Child Behavior Checklist; CBT, Cognitive Behavioral Therapy; CDI, Children’s Depression Inventory; CFT, Conjoint Family Therapy; CGI, Clinical Global Impression; EAT, Eating Attitudes Test; ED, Eating Disorder; EDI, Eating Disorders Inventory; EDE, Eating Disorders Examination; FAM-II, Family Assessment Measure; FGP, Family Group Psychoeducation; FLX, Fluoxetine; FLV, Fluvoxamine; FT, Family-Based Therapy; FOC, Focal therapy; g, Group Therapy; GAF, Global Assessment of Functioning; HRSD, Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression; IPT, Interpersonal Psychotherapy; K-SADS, Kiddie Schedule of Affective Disorders; LTFT, Long Term Family Therapy; MOCI, Maudsley Obsessive Compulsive Index; M-R, Morgan-Russell Outcome; NST, Nonspecific Supportive Therapy; NUT, Nutritional Counseling; PAI, Personality Assessment Inventory; PL, Placebo; RSES, Rosenberg Self Esteem Scale; SFT, Separated Family Therapy; SMFQ, Short Mood and Feelings Questionnaire; STFT, Short Term Family Therapy; TFEQ, Three Factor Eating Questionnaire; TOP, Topiramate; WL, Wait List Control; YCB-EDS, Yale Cornell Brown ED Scale.