Skip to main content
. 2012 Jul 16;39(8):4679–4690. doi: 10.1118/1.4730505

Table 3.

Range of agreement and bias normalized to the mean feature value as a function of the registration algorithm used to register the follow-up to the baseline CT scan. All features with nRoA ≤ 15% for at least one registration method are listed.

  Demons
B-splines
Affine
Rigid
  nRoA (%) Bias (%) nRoA (%) Bias (%) nRoA (%) Bias (%) nRoA (%) Bias (%)
First-order features
 Minimum 9.92 3.07 12.70 −3.62 8.17 1.18 8.26 1.13
 Mean 7.56 0.01 16.91 −0.27 18.50 −0.36 19.76 −0.41
 Median 7.28 −0.11 11.40 −0.44 11.83 −0.32 11.57 −0.37
 Entropy (binned) 14.68 −3.86 19.47 −0.26 21.18 −1.74 22.92 −1.74
 Entropy (unbinned) 10.33 −4.30 12.54 0.95 13.26 −1.85 14.34 −1.84
 5% quantile 11.04 4.30 10.44 −0.07 11.33 2.45 11.37 2.39
 30% quantile 7.49 1.37 9.73 −0.36 9.86 0.59 9.59 0.54
 70% quantile 9.10 −1.50 19.03 −0.50 22.11 −1.13 24.02 −1.18
Fractal features
 Box-counting dimension 11.80 −5.49 19.41 −0.41 21.22 −3.65 23.00 −3.68
 Coarse dimension 14.64 −2.34 33.22 −0.06 37.35 −1.54 38.89 −1.62
 Brownian dimension 4.50 −1.15 9.44 −0.09 12.15 −0.76 13.11 −0.77
Laws’ filter features
 E5L5 entropy 10.79 −2.16 24.09 0.25 26.42 −1.44 30.02 −1.46
 R5L5 entropy 14.41 −3.53 20.89 −0.74 22.09 −4.79 23.80 −4.79
 S5L5 entropy 11.70 −3.26 24.83 0.22 27.34 −2.57 30.66 −2.58
 W5L5 entropy 12.69 −4.05 22.31 −0.07 24.31 −3.84 26.77 −3.86
GLCM features
 Difference average 11.47 0.19 13.98 −4.12 10.44 −0.90 10.73 −0.95
 Sum of squares variance 1.47 −0.29 3.75 −0.01 4.43 −0.25 5.06 −0.24
 Sum average 5.78 −1.27 12.51 1.35 12.75 −0.74 13.83 −0.75
Sum variance
11.67
−2.52
25.78
2.73
26.54
−1.46
28.83
−1.49
Mean nRoA 9.91   16.97   17.96   19.29  
p1   1 × 10−5   4 × 10−5   3 × 10−5  
1

Compared with mean nRoA for demons registration.