Table 4.
Authors | Control Group Treatment | Exercises Performed | Exercise Variables | Nonexercise Care | Treatment Period and Frequency |
Dursun et al53 | Exercise only | Quadriceps setting, straight-leg raises, hip adductor strengthening, terminal knee extensions, and closed kinetic chain exercises; hamstrings, triceps surae, iliotibial band, and quadriceps stretching; proprioception training; bicycling | Duty cycle 10:20 s | NA | 4 wk, 5 d/wk (EMGB group wore the device only 3/5 weekly sessions) |
Yip and Ng49 | Exercise only | Quadriceps, hamstrings, gastrocnemius, hip adductors, and iliotibial band flexibility; quadriceps setting, terminal knee extension, semisquat, wall slide, lunge, step-up, step-down, eccentric hamstrings exercise, and hip adduction exercises; balance and proprioception training; plyometric and agility training | NA | NA | 8-wk daily home exercise program |
Draper50 | Exercise only | Quadriceps setting, straight-leg raises, active and passive range of motion, isokinetic exercises | 1 wk postoperatively: 10 repetitions2 wk: increased repetitions4 wk: straight-leg raises, 5 sets of 10 each in prone, supine, and side-lying position | Electric stimulation progress to weight bearing tolerated at 12 wk | 12 wk (18 or 26 sessions, depending on the patient's schedule) |
Draper and Ballard51 | Exercise and electrotherapy | Quadriceps setting, straight-leg raises, active and active-assistive range of motion, hamstrings stretching, isotonic knee extension and flexion exercises | Duty cycle 10:20 s (in conjunction with EMGB or electrotherapy), 3 sets of 10 (wk 1–2), 5 sets of 10 (wk 3–6), progressively increasing intensity | Progress to weight bearing as tolerated at 4 wk | 6 wk total wk 1–4: daily home exercise program, 3×/d wk 5–6: 3 sessions/wk at rehabilitation clinic |
Kirnap et al54 | Exercise only | Phase 1: quadriceps setting, straight-leg raises Phase 2: hip adductor strengthening and terminal knee extension added Phase 3: closed kinetic chain exercises and lateral step-up exercises added | Duty cycle 5:10 s over 20 cycles | Cryotherapy and patellar mobilization | 2 wk, 5 d/wk |
Levitt et al55 | Exercise only | Quadriceps setting | Duty cycle 5:10 s | NA | 10-d home exercise program, 3×/d |
Durmus et al52 | Exercise and electrotherapy | Isometric knee extension (EMGB at 25°–30° knee flexion, electrotherapy at 60° knee flexion) | EMGB duty cycle 10:50 s, electrotherapy duty cycle 10:10 s | NA | 4 wk, 5 d/wk |
Yilmaz et al56 | Exercise only | Quadriceps isometrics, minisquats, hip adductor isometrics, 4-way straight-leg raises, terminal knee extension | 10 repetitions | NA | 3 wk, 3×/d, both supervised group and home exercise programs |
Abbreviations: EMGB, electromyographic biofeedback; NA, not available.