Table 2.
Overview of EHF vaccines
System | % protection, number of vaccinations, time required for vaccination schemea) | Remarks | Key references | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|
NHPs | guinea pigs | mice | |||
Non-replicating vaccines | |||||
inactivated ebolavirus | 10%b), 3, 11w | 64%, 3, 21w | 100%, 2, 4w | 38, 39 | |
replicons | 0%, 3, 15w | 100%, 3, 22w | 100%, 2, 8w | 39, 40 | |
DNA | n/a | 100%, 3, 19w | 100%, 2, 8w | safe and inmmunogenic in human phase 1 clinical trials | 43-45 |
DNA + Ad5 | 100%, 4, 32w | n/a | n/a | 44 | |
Ad5 | 100%, 1, 4w | 100%, 1, 4w | 100%, 1, 3w | safe and inmmunogenic in human phase 1 clinical trials; problems with preexisting immunity, but this can be overcome by multiple vaccinations | 46, 50, 53, 55 |
baculovirus-derived GP | n/a | 50%, 3, 11w | n/a | 58 | |
recombinant GP-Fc fusion protein | n/a | n/a | 83%, 4, 11w | 59 | |
GP-immunocomplexes | n/a | n/a | 80%, 4, 12w | 60 | |
VLPs | 100%, 3, 15w | n/a | 100%, 2, 7w | 63, 64 | |
rEBOVΔVP30 | n/a | 100%, 2, 9w | 100%, 2, 11w | 68 | |
inactivated rRABV (BSNP333-GP) | n/a | n/a | 100%, 1, 11w | only inactivated vaccine shown to protect after a single vaccination; extensive experiences with this vaccine platform for wildlife vaccination | 89 |
Replicating vaccines | |||||
rVSV/ΔG/GP | 100%, 1, 4wc) | 100%, 1, 3wc) | 100%, 1, 1dc) | capable of post-exposure protection | 69-71, 91 |
rHPIV3/GP | 100%, 2, 10w | 100%, 1, 4w | n/a | potential problems with preexisting immunity | 85, 86 |
rHPIV3/ΔHN-F/GP | n/a | 100%, 1, 4w | n/a | no problems with preexisting immunity | 87 |
rRABV (BNSPΔG-GP) | n/a | n/a | 100%, 1, 11w | 89 | |
rCMV | n/a | n/a | 100%, 2, 10w | disseminating vaccine | 90 |
abbreviations: w = weeks, d = days, n/a = no data from challenge experiments available
no protection was observed in 8 cynomolgus macaques; however, 1 out of 2 rhesus macaques was protected
postexposure vaccination protects 50% of NHPs and 83% of guinea pigs if given 0.5 to 1 hour post infection, and 100% of mice as late as 24 hours post infection