Skip to main content
. 2012 Aug 17;7(8):e43607. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0043607

Table 1. Volatile emissiona by Brassica nigra HR+ (+) or HR− (−) plants in response to eggs of Pieris brassicae (PB) and Mamestra brassicae (MB) sampled at 24 or 72 h after oviposition.

Treatment → Uninfested 24PB− 24PB+ 72PB− 72PB+ 24MB−
ID Compound ↓ (N = 25) (N = 5) (N = 5) (N = 5) (N = 5) (N = 5)
Aliphatic
1 2-Methylpropanal 11.56±2.2 7.97±1.5 17.93±4.8 3.57±0.8* 6.63±1.0 4.47±1.3
2 2-Methyl-2-propenal 23.78±4.6 12.19±0.5* 34.63±9.7 5.36±1.3 8.06±1.2 9.26±1.5
3 Ethyl acetate 134.44±25.9 2.92±0.9 21.81±8.0 3.69±1.2 4.29±1.5 12.75±10.4
4 2-Methyl-1-propanol 4.41±0.8 3.82±1.2 6.49±2.8 1.42±0.4 4.18±1.5 1.48±0.4
6 2-Butenal 10.70±2.1 7.28±1.1 17.93±5.9 3.25±0.6* 4.23±0.6 3.85±0.4
7 3-Methylbutanal 12.33±2.4 8.16±1.8 17.44±3.1 5.63±1.8 6.64±1.4 4.45±0.6
8 2-Methylbutanal 8.37±1.6 5.46±2.1 11.08±2.9 4.85±2.4 4.50±1.1 2.89±0.3
9 1-Methoxy-2-propanol 134.94±26.0 192.25±81.7 244.20±78.9 41.31±10.6 87.75±53.5 63.17±14.1
10 1-Penten-3-ol 189.90±36.5 64.13±9.9 396.15±115.0 34.91±15.8* 253.93±134.9 187.68±61.9
11 2-Pentanone 43.81±8.4 47.31±19.5 39.54±11.6 8.06±2.0* 15.20±2.9 18.20±5.5
12 3-Pentanone 53.60±10.3 36.34±22.2 68.65±29.7 8.25±2.0* 78.72±43.8 37.48±12.4
15 4-Methyl-2-pentanone 7.08±1.4 3.92±1.3 6.57±1.9 1.34±0.3 2.23±0.3 2.41±1.1
17 (E)-2-Pentenal 2.53±0.5 1.10±0.3 3.15±1.4 0.31±0.2* 1.28±0.5 1.67±0.7
18 2,4-Pentanedione 55.07±10.6 112.50±89.9 45.09±14.0 2.45±1.2 16.10±7.7 11.76±3.6
19 4-Methyl-3-penten-2-one 68.92±13.3 64.25±35.2 37.59±7.7 8.67±2.5* 23.77±11.2 15.84±5.8
20 (Z)-3-Hexen-1-ol 215.11±41.4 44.56±12.6 179.94±74.5 18.05±6.4* 43.50±18.3 174.64±109.8
23 6-Methyl-2-heptanone 29.31±5.6 17.21±2.5 34.10±4.7 6.63±0.7* 15.83±2.8 16.36±2.8
24 (Z)-3-Hexen-1-yl acetate 573.69±110.4 105.04±18.8 422.09±111.9 45.69±12.3* 171.72±65.4 478.74±173.1
28 Methyl 2-ethylhexanoate 2.81±0.5 1.47±0.7 3.69±1.1 1.29±0.5* 1.98±0.7 0.87±0.5
38 Undecan-2-one 13.61±2.6 11.20±1.0 20.18±4.3 3.94±0.6* 8.54±1.6 7.93±0.8
Aromatic
30 o-Cresol 36.76±7.1 33.26±15.6 49.88±7.9 7.51±1.2* 17.50±2.7 18.05±3.4
33 2-Phenylacetonitrile (benzyl cyanide) 8.91±1.7 4.82±0.6 10.27±4.4 1.91±0.3* 4.39±0.8 3.31±0.9
47 Lilial 18.95±3.6 5.10±0.6 20.95±3.6 2.71±0.5* 20.12±9.6 14.48±8.4
49 2-Ethylhexyl salicylate 5.76±1.1 4.92±3.4 15.31±6.3 1.73±1.4 5.74±3.0 10.85±4.8
Terpenoids
22 α-Pinene 55.24±10.6 22.78±7.1 109.40±44.9 11.74±3.3 12.47±4.4 24.32±12.7
25 3-Carene 48.16±9.3 17.96±8.9 75.99±22.3 5.72±1.5* 13.73±4.7 25.93±13.3
26 (S)-Limonene 68.75±13.2 29.85±11.9 76.41±25.6 14.19±5.4 10.70±3.8 39.98±32.5
27 α -Phellandrene 10.15±2.0 10.19±4.8 11.52±3.0 1.83±0.8* 11.75±7.0 10.99±2.6
29 (E)-β-Ocimene 5.97±1.1 22.69±6.6* 82.28±42.2* 4.55±2.1 5.42±2.0 3.68±2.0
32 p-Mentha-1,5,8-triene 8.91±1.7 3.60±0.9 14.75±3.2 1.63±0.7* 3.01±0.7 4.36±1.3
34 Isopulegon 2.75±0.5 1.20±0.3 4.04±1.0 0.55±0.1* 1.20±0.2 1.42±0.4
35 p-Menthan-3-one 4.62±0.9 1.67±0.7 4.02±1.9 27.09±25.8 23.60±21.9 2.53±1.6
36 Isomenthone 2.50±0.5 2.36±0.3 3.30±0.2 10.65±10.0 10.79±8.8* 1.44±0.7
Treatment → Uninfested 24PB− 24PB+ 72PB− 72PB+ 24MB−
ID Compound ↓ (N = 25) (N = 5) (N = 5) (N = 5) (N = 5) (N = 5)
37 Menthol 25.64±4.9 14.95±4.4 31.32±7.1 47.74±42.9 53.01±40.8 14.64±2.8
39 7-α-H-Silphiperfol-5-ene 88.22±17.0 151.09±61.2 363.17±116.3 13.70±13.5 15.88±15.9
40 Presilphiperfol-7-ene 13.36±2.6 15.13±7.6 83.12±34.4 0.06±0.1 6.81±6.8 0.61±0.6
41 7-β-H-Silphiperfol-5-ene 32.16±6.2 46.07±17.4 143.24±55.6 4.82±4.8 5.11±5.1
43 Silphiperfol-6-ene 10.09±1.9 17.14±9.2 40.07±15.8 2.42±2.4 1.81±1.8
44 α-Funebrene 10.80±2.1 29.44±23.7 8.42±8.4 4.81±2.1 11.26±4.5* 18.37±10.6
45 Longifolen 13.10±2.5 6.66±2.1 17.41±3.1 4.02±1.3 20.06±13.4 6.71±2.2
48 Guaiazulene 10.04±1.9 5.57±1.7 11.40±3.2 2.29±0.7* 3.17±1.4 5.00±1.1
50 Cembrene 16.90±3.3 14.07±8.7 54.27±16.6 1.28±0.8 15.73±3.5 9.78±1.5
N and/or S containing
16 1,2-Dimethyldisulfide 66.36±12.8 39.86±8.1 420.67±341.7 33.40±20.2 19.96±2.1 22.90±5,2*
21 Allyl isothiocyanate 393.18±75.7 63.65±38.0 782.07±391.7 53.90±20.8* 147.79±50.1 641.32±565.5
46 2-Phenylethyl isothiocyanate 13.86±2.7 3.06±1.0 20.23±7.8 1.06±0.4* 10.81±2.9 3.92±0.9*
Cyclic/Heterocyclic
5 Tetrahydrofuran 2.49±0.5 1.96±0.2 4.66±1.3 1.37±0.4 1.07±0.2 1.65±0.8
13 Methylcyclohexane 11.56±2.2 5.20±0.8 19.64±8.4 3.79±1.7 4.08±1.2 6.73±2.3
14 Pyrazine 9.15±1.8 7.32±2.4 12.03±2.5 3.58±1.4 3.28±1.0 3.38±0.5*
31 2,2,6-Trimethyl-4-methylene-2H-pyran 21.35±4.1 55.11±47.3 12.36±2.9 3.43±1.9 6.20±2.3 9.69±5.5
42 4-(3-Cyclohexen-1-yl)-3-buten-2-one 4.65±0.9 5.58±1.8 9.73±4.0 1.51±0.8 1.19±0.7 4.60±1.2
a

Volatile emissions are given in mean peak area ± SEM/g fresh weight of foliage divided by 105 with the number of replicates between brackets.

*

values with asterisk indicate significant differences in emission quantities between oviposition-induced B. nigra and uninfested control for each treatment (Mann-Whitney U-test).