Table 1. Summary of abnormal dendritic spine phenotypes reported in Fmr1 KO mice.
Region → | Cortex | Hippocampus | Cerebellum | Olfactory bulb | Amygdala |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Phenotype ↓ | |||||
Increased spine density |
Layer 2/3: | Pyramidal cells in CA1: | Granule cells: | Pyramidal-like neurons: | |
Dolen et al., 2007 (P30) | Levenga et al., 2011a (25 weeks, CA1) | Scotto-Lomassese et al., 2011 (2 months) | Qin et al., 2011 (~3 months) | ||
Hayashi et al., 2007 (2 months) | |||||
Liu et al., 2010 (12 weeks) | |||||
Granule cells in dentate gyrus: | |||||
Layer 5: | Grossman et al., 2010 (P15-60) | ||||
Nimchinsky et al., 2001 (P7) | |||||
℘Su et al., 2011 (1, 7, 8 weeks) | Whole hippocampus dissociated: | ||||
Comery et al., 1997 (16 weeks) | Antar et al., 2006 (P0+16div) | ||||
McKinney et al., 2005 (P60-90) | Swanger et al., 2011(E17+18div) | ||||
Galvez & Greenough, 2005 (P73) | |||||
Normal spine density |
Layer 2/3: | Pyramidal cells in CA1: | Purkinje neurons: | ||
Cruz-Martin et al., 2010 (P7–P21) | Grossman et al., 2006 (P60–P90) | Koekkoek et al., 2005 (adult) | |||
Meredith et al., 2007 (P14-23) | |||||
Whole hippocampus dissociated: | |||||
Layer 4: | Braun & Segal, 2000 (P0+7div) | ||||
Harlow et al., 2010 (P7, P14) | Su et al., 2011 (P0+8 div) | ||||
†Levenga et al., 2011b | |||||
Layer 5: | (E16+14div) | ||||
Nimchinsky et al., 2001 (P14, P28) | *Segal et al. 2003 (P1+14div) | ||||
de Vrij et al., 2008 (E18+21div) | |||||
Galvez & Greenough, 2005 (P25) | |||||
Restivo et al., 2005 (12 weeks) | |||||
Pan et al., 2010 (P30) | |||||
Irwin et al., 2002 (60–90 days) | |||||
Relative immaturity of spines |
Layer 2/3: | Pyramidal cells in CA1: | Purkinje neurons: | Granule cells: | Pyramidal-like neurons: |
Cruz-Martin et al., 2010 (P10-12; higher turnover; more filopodia / fewer mushroom spines) | Bilousova et al., 2009 (P7; more filopodia / fewer mushroom) | Koekkoek et al., 2005 (adult; longer) | Scotto-Lomassese et al., 2011 (2 months; longer) | Qin et al., 2011 (~3 months; longer) | |
Grossman et al., 2006 (P60–P90; longer, more immature morphology) | |||||
Meredith et al., 2007 (P14-23; longer) | ¥Levenga et al., 2011a (25 weeks; more filopodia / fewer mushroom) | ||||
Liu et al., 2010 (13 weeks; longer) | |||||
Layer 5: | Granule cells in dentate gyrus: | ||||
Su et al., 2011 (1, 2, 7, 8 weeks; longer) | Grossman et al., 2010 (P15–P60; more immature morphology) | ||||
Nimchinsky et al., 2001 (P7–P28) | Whole hippocampus dissociated: | ||||
Pan et al., 2010 (P20, P30; high turnover) | |||||
Comery et al., 1997 (16 weeks; longer) | Antar et al., 2006 (P0+16div; longer, more filopodia / fewer spine synapses) | ||||
Restivo 2005 (12 weeks; more immature morphology) | de Vrij et al., 2008 (E18+21div; longer, more filopodia / fewer mature spines) | ||||
Irwin et al., 2002 (60–90 days; more immature morphology) | Su et al., 2011 (P0+8div; longer) | ||||
Galvez & Greenough, 2005 (P73; longer, more immature morphology) | ‡Levenga et al., 2011b (E16+14div; longer) | ||||
Bilousova et al., 2009 (E15+14div; longer) | |||||
McKinney et al., 2005 (P60–P90; longer, more immature morphology) | Swanger et al., 2011 (E17+18div; longer, more filopodia / fewer mushroom) |
In this study, spine density in somatosensory cortex was elevated at 1, 7 and 8 weeks of age, but not at 2 weeks.
This is the only study that has reported a decrease in spine density in neocortical neurons (dissociated, E16+20div).
This study actually reported a lower than normal spine density in Fmr1 KO mice.
This study found that spines were not immature in CA3; also, they found no change in average spine length.
This study found that spine length was normal in neocortical neurons (dissociated, E16+20div).