Table 3.
Characteristics and effectiveness of interventions with a short-term follow-up period (<6 months)
Study | Medication for | Type of reminder | Study quality | Short-term effect* on adherence measured with: | ||
Electronic monitoring | Self-report | Pill count | ||||
Hou et al30 | Contraception | SMS | High | – | – | |
Hardy et al28 | HIV | SMS | High | ++ | – | – |
Strandbygaard et al31 | Asthma | SMS | High | ++ | ||
Charles et al34 | Asthma | ERD | High | ++ | ||
Andrade et al36 | HIV | ERD | High | + | – | |
Ho et al33 | Glaucoma | ERD | Low | ++ | ||
Santschi et al35 | Hypertension | ERD | Low | – | ||
Da Costa et al37 | Hypertension | ERD | Low | ++ | ||
Laster et al38 | Glaucoma | ERD | Low | ++ | ++† | |
Safren et al40 | HIV | pager | Low | ++ |
++= Overall effect; + = subgroup effect; – = no effect.
Amount of eye drops left estimated by bottle weight.
ERD, electronic reminder device; SMS, short message service.