Table 4. Pearson correlation coefficients of pathogen abundance within randomly sampled individual worker bees from colonies with an observable Nosema infection but no characteristics of CCD.
Pathogen pair | Correlation | Number ofco-infected bees | P-value | |
CBPV | ABPV | 0.547 | 66 | <0.0001* |
DWV | NA | 0.604 | 45 | <0.0001* |
DWV | NC | 0.639 | 35 | <0.0001* |
DWV | CBPV | 0.500 | 57 | <0.0001* |
SBV | ABPV | 0.528 | 71 | <0.0001* |
SBV | CBPV | 0.538 | 67 | <0.0001* |
DWV | BQCV | 0.411 | 62 | 0.001* |
NC | NA | 0.482 | 34 | 0.004* |
SBV | NC | 0.427 | 42 | 0.005* |
BQCV | NC | 0.410 | 41 | 0.008* |
CBPV | BQCV | 0.322 | 63 | 0.010* |
CBPV | NC | 0.381 | 40 | 0.015* |
IAPV | CBPV | 0.283 | 69 | 0.018* |
IAPV | ABPV | 0.238 | 74 | 0.041 |
ABPV | NC | 0.304 | 43 | 0.048 |
DWV | ABPV | 0.248 | 62 | 0.052 |
BQCV | ABPV | 0.219 | 68 | 0.073 |
SBV | DWV | 0.229 | 62 | 0.074 |
SBV | BQCV | 0.200 | 68 | 0.103 |
SBV | IAPV | 0.168 | 74 | 0.153 |
BQCV | NA | 0.181 | 49 | 0.214 |
IAPV | NA | −0.159 | 55 | 0.247 |
SBV | NA | 0.159 | 53 | 0.257 |
IAPV | BQCV | 0.042 | 71 | 0.731 |
CBPV | NA | 0.039 | 49 | 0.792 |
IAPV | NC | −0.022 | 44 | 0.887 |
ABPV | NA | −0.009 | 55 | 0.950 |
IAPV | DWV | −0.001 | 65 | 0.991 |
These samples tested whether pathogen covariation occurred at the level of individual Nosema-exposed bees, outside of a CCD context. N equals the number of co-infected bees upon which the correlation is calculated for each pathogen pair, out of a total of 77 bees tested. CBPV = Chronic bee paralysis virus; ABPV = acute bee paralysis virus; DWV = deformed wing virus; SBV = sacbrood virus; BQCV = black queen cell virus; IAPV = Israeli acute paralysis virus; NC = Nosema ceranae; NA = Nosema apis. Asterisk indicates a significant comparison after Bonferroni correction for multiple tests.