Skip to main content
. 2012 Aug 21;7(8):e43562. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0043562

Table 4. Pearson correlation coefficients of pathogen abundance within randomly sampled individual worker bees from colonies with an observable Nosema infection but no characteristics of CCD.

Pathogen pair Correlation Number ofco-infected bees P-value
CBPV ABPV 0.547 66 <0.0001*
DWV NA 0.604 45 <0.0001*
DWV NC 0.639 35 <0.0001*
DWV CBPV 0.500 57 <0.0001*
SBV ABPV 0.528 71 <0.0001*
SBV CBPV 0.538 67 <0.0001*
DWV BQCV 0.411 62 0.001*
NC NA 0.482 34 0.004*
SBV NC 0.427 42 0.005*
BQCV NC 0.410 41 0.008*
CBPV BQCV 0.322 63 0.010*
CBPV NC 0.381 40 0.015*
IAPV CBPV 0.283 69 0.018*
IAPV ABPV 0.238 74 0.041
ABPV NC 0.304 43 0.048
DWV ABPV 0.248 62 0.052
BQCV ABPV 0.219 68 0.073
SBV DWV 0.229 62 0.074
SBV BQCV 0.200 68 0.103
SBV IAPV 0.168 74 0.153
BQCV NA 0.181 49 0.214
IAPV NA −0.159 55 0.247
SBV NA 0.159 53 0.257
IAPV BQCV 0.042 71 0.731
CBPV NA 0.039 49 0.792
IAPV NC −0.022 44 0.887
ABPV NA −0.009 55 0.950
IAPV DWV −0.001 65 0.991

These samples tested whether pathogen covariation occurred at the level of individual Nosema-exposed bees, outside of a CCD context. N equals the number of co-infected bees upon which the correlation is calculated for each pathogen pair, out of a total of 77 bees tested. CBPV = Chronic bee paralysis virus; ABPV = acute bee paralysis virus; DWV = deformed wing virus; SBV = sacbrood virus; BQCV = black queen cell virus; IAPV = Israeli acute paralysis virus; NC = Nosema ceranae; NA = Nosema apis. Asterisk indicates a significant comparison after Bonferroni correction for multiple tests.