Table 1.
Source | Age, years | Gender | Site | Duration | Size, cm | Bone/LN Involvement | Histologic grade | Treatment | Recurrence/Interval | Follow-up |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Tipton [10] |
1.5 |
Male |
Buccal mucosa |
NS |
1.0 |
NS |
Poorly differentiated |
Wide local excision |
No |
NED 6 years |
Budnick [11] |
12 |
Female |
Hard palate |
NS |
2.0 |
Bone: NSLN: NS |
Low |
Excision down to bone |
No |
NED 3 years |
Gustafsson et al. [12] |
13 |
Female |
Hard palate |
2 months |
1.5 |
Bone: NoLN: NS |
Low |
Resection of the tumor |
No |
NED 1.5 years |
Lack and Upton [13] |
18 |
Female |
Upper lipa |
NS |
NS |
Bone: NSLN: NS |
Low to focally intermediate |
Near total maxillectomy |
No |
NED 8 years |
Fonseca et al. [1] |
14 |
Male |
Soft palate |
NS |
NS |
Bone: NSLN: No |
Low |
1st surgery2nd surgery |
Yes/5 years |
NED, NS |
Fonseca et al. [1] |
14 |
Female |
Soft palate |
NS |
NS |
Bone: NSLN: No |
Low |
Surgery |
No |
NED 6 months |
April et al. [14] |
10 |
Female |
Junction of the hard/soft palate |
Nasal congestion × 1 month |
0.5 |
Bone: erosion into left naresLN: No |
Intermediate |
NS |
NS |
NS |
Aguiar et al. [15] |
13 |
Female |
Junction of the hard/soft palate |
7 months |
3.0 |
Bone: NoLN: No |
NS |
Excision |
No |
NED 4 months |
Winslow et al. [16] |
10 |
Female |
Buccal mucosa |
NS |
NS |
Bone: NoLN: No |
Intermediate |
Wide local excision |
NS |
NS |
Flaitz [17] |
8 |
Male |
Hard palate |
9 months |
2.0 |
Bone: NoLN: No |
Low |
Wide local excision down to periosteum |
NS |
NS |
Caccamese and Ord [18] |
17 |
Male |
Left junction of the hard/soft palate |
NS |
1.5 |
Bone: NoLN: No |
Low |
Local resection |
No |
NED 94 months |
Caccamese and Ord [18] |
14 |
Female |
Hard palate |
1 month |
1.0 |
Bone: NoLN: No |
Low to intermediate |
Excision |
No |
NED 62 months |
Caccamese and Ord [18] |
22b |
Male |
Palate, NOS |
7 years |
2.0 |
Bone: NoLN: No |
Low |
Excision with 1.0cm margins |
No |
NED 34 months |
Caccamese and Ord [18] |
16 |
Female |
Junction of the soft palate and anterior pillar |
1 year |
2.5 |
Bone: NoLN: No |
Low to intermediate |
Local resection |
No |
NED 42 months |
Moraes et al. [19] |
14 |
Female |
Left hard palate |
1 year |
5 |
Bone: YesLN: No |
Low |
Transoral resection |
No |
NED 4 years |
LSUSD |
15 |
Female |
Left hard palate |
3 weeks |
NS |
Bone: NoLN: No |
Low |
Excision |
No |
NED 21 years |
LSUSD |
14 |
Female |
Right hard palate |
NS |
3.0 |
Bone: YesLN: NS |
Low |
Excision |
No |
NED 19 years |
LSUSD |
15 |
Female |
Left hard palate |
NS |
NS |
Bone: NSLN: NS |
Low |
NS |
No |
NED 9 years |
LSUSD |
18 |
Female |
Left hard palate |
3 weeks |
NS |
Bone: NSLN: NS |
Low |
Excision |
No |
NED 8 years |
LSUSD | 19 | Male | Right junction of the hard/soft palate | ‘Forever’ | 2.0 | Bone: NoLN: NoLungs: No | Low to intermediate | Wide surgical excision with ‘alveolar bone biopsy’ | No | NED 2 years |
aReported as ‘buccal sulcus anteriorly in the premaxillary area’. bLesion followed for seven years (since the age of 15). LSUSD, Louisiana State University School of Dentistry; LN, lymph node; NED, no evidence of disease; NOS, not further specified; NS, not stated.