Skip to main content
. 2012 Aug 24;7(8):e43739. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0043739

Table 9. Impact of the physicians’ clinical suspicion of TB (CSTB) on the sensitivity of smear microscopy in tuberculosis patients according to disease localization and HIV status.

Pulmonary TB Extrapulmonary TB
TB diagnosis*CSTB LowCSTB HighCSTB Very High p value “TB diagnosis vs very high" TB diagnosisCSTB LowCSTB HighCSTB Very High p value “TB diagnosis vs very high"
N of AFB-positive/N of patients within the group N of AFB-positive/N of patients within the group
(%) (%)
HIV-infected 38/90 0/1 21/56 18/32 0.2 3/31 0/2 2/19 1/10 1
(42.2) (0) (37.5) (56.2) (9.7%) (0) (10.5) (10.0)
HIV-infected 205/270 0/1 39/83 167/186 0.0002 9/46 ( - 7/37 2/9 1
(75.9) (0) (47.0) (89.8) 19.6%) (18.9) (22.2)
HIV-unknown 180/293 0/5 48/134 133/154 0.0001 13/67 0/2 11/58 2/7 0.6
(61.4) (0) (26.1) (74.8) (19.4%) (0) (19.0) (28.6)
Total 423/653 0/7 107/273 318/372 0.0001 25/144 0/4 20/114 5/26 0.7
(64.8) (0) (39.2) (85.5) (16.6) (0) (17.5) (19.2)

TB: tuberculosis; AFB: acid fast bacilli. *TB diagnosis by SM within the group considered; CSTB: clinical suspicion of TB