Skip to main content
. 2012 Aug 24;7(8):e43739. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0043739

Table 10. Comparative frequency of positive results of liquid versus solid culture in pulmonary and extrapulmonary active tuberculosis patients according to HIV status.

Pulmonary TB Extrapulmonary-TB
Liquid culture Solid culture Total p value of liquid vs solid cultures* Liquid culture Solid culture Total p value of liquid vs solid cultures*
Positive over total (%) Positive over total (%)
HIV-infected 55/86** 38/87** 56/87** 0.3 14/30 1/33 15/33 0.2
(64.0) (43.7) (64.4) (46.7) (30.3) (45.5 )
HIV-uninfected 218/269** 184/268** 225/270 0.0001 27/46 20/45 29/46 0.2
(81.0) (68.7) (83.3) (58.7) (44.4) (63.0)
HIV-unknown 238/293 164/293 245/293 0.0001 39/67 27/67 39/67 0.03
(81.2) (56.0) (83.6) (58.2) (40.3) (48.2)
Total 511/648 386/648 526/650 0.0001 80/143 57/145 83/146 0.004
(78.9) (59.6) (80.9) (55.9) (39.3) (56.8)

TB: tuberculosis; HIV: Human Immunodeficiency Virus; CI: confidence interval. *:p value of Comparison. **missing recorded culture;