Table 2.
Author(s) and year, definition of off-shift | Multisite (no. sites), patient sample size | Outcome(s) | Poor quality outcomes |
---|---|---|---|
Nights | |||
Caughey et al. (2008), Evening: 1800–0001, Night: 0001–0700 | N, 34,046 | Mortality and Apgar scores | N |
Badr et al. (2007), Night: 2300–0700 | Y (4), 5152 | Mortality, asphyxia, neonatal morbidity | Y |
Urato et al. (2006), Night: 2301–0759 | Registry, 80 cases, 999 controls | Mortality | Y |
Gould et al. (2005), Early night: 1900–0059 Late night: 0100–0659 | Registry, 3,363,157 | Mortality | Y |
Luo and Karlberg (2001), Night: 2100–0700 | Registry, 2,102,324 | Mortality | Y |
Stewart et al. (1998), Night: 2100–0859 | Registry, 1015 | Mortality | Y |
Nights and weekends | |||
Bell et al. (2010)*, Early night: 1701–2259, Late night: 0000–0759 Weekend: Sat and Sun | Registry, 11,137 | Mortality within 7 and 28 days, short-term morbidity and neurodevelopmental outcomes of low birth weight infants | N |
Stephansson et al. (2003)*, Night: 2000–0759, Weekend: Sat and Sun | Registry, 694,888 | Mortality | Y |
Y, yes; N, no.
Analysed nights and weekends separately.