Skip to main content
. 2012 Aug 14;2(8):e153. doi: 10.1038/tp.2012.78

Table 1. Summary of included studies.

Author Mean age (year) N of OCDa N of male OCDa N of HCa N of male NHCa Diagnostic tool Duration of illness (year) Psychiatric comorbidity Medication Y-BOCSb
Magnetic field strength (tesla) Segmentation MRS sequence Single- vs multi- voxel Types of measure TE (ms) TR (ms) NAA Cre Cho mI Glx VOI location VOI size (ml) Results
                    Total Obsession Compulsion                              
Atmaca et al.51 28.1 18 6 18 6 DSM-IV 5.5 No No 17.2 NA NA 1.5 Undone NA Single Cre ratio 15.6 2000 × × bl.hippocampus 4.7 NAA↓
Bartha et al.50 34.9 13 7 13 7 DSM-IV NA No No 25.9 11.6 14.3 1.5 Undone NA Single Absolute 20 1500 lt.corpus striatum 4.5 NAA↓
Beédard et al.43 40.54 13 4 12 4 DSM-IV 12.77 No Medicated 26.5 12.92 13.62 1.5 Undone PROBE Single Cre ratio 102 3100 × rt.OFA 8 NS
                                        × lt.OFA 8 NS
                                        × rt.MTL 8 NS
                                        × lt.MTL 8 NS
                                        × rt.thalamus 9 NS
                                        × lt.thalamus 9 NS
                                        × ACC 9.6 NS
Besiroglu et al.42 32.1 30 12 15 6 DSM-IV 6.35 No No 24.15 13.1 11.05 1.5 Undone PRESS Single Absolute Cre ratio 135 1500 × × rt.ACC 8 NAA↓
                                        × × rt.AHC 4.096 NAA↓
Ebert et al.34 27 12 8 6 5 DSM-IV 11 No No 28 NA NA 2 Undone PRESS Single Cre ratio 30 1500 × ACC 8 NAA↓
                                        × rt.striatum 8 NAA↓
                                        × rt.PL 8 NS
Fan et al.24 25.62 21 12 19 13 DSM-IV 4.45 No No 22.52 NA NA 1.5 Undone PRESS Single Cre ratio 35 1500 × × MPFC 8 NAA↓
Jang et al.22 27.77 13 8 13 8 DSM-IV 7.23 Two: depression No 30.23 15.31 14.92 1.5 Done PRESS Multi Cre ratio 272 2000 × × × × ACC 1.125 NAA↓
                                        × × × × FWM 1.125 NAA↓
                                        × × × × Prefrontal cortex 1.125 NAA↓
                                        × × × × PC 1.125 NS
                                        × × × × PWM 1.125 NS
                                        × × × × Posterior cingulate 1.125 NS
Kitamura et al.26 22.7 12 3 32 10 DSM-IV 6.3 No Medicated 20.4 NA NA 3 Undone PRESS Single Cre ratio 24 6000 × × × ACC 3 NS
                                        × × × lt.basal ganglia 6.75 NS
                                        × × × lt.thalamus 3.375 NS
                                        × × × lt.FWM 3.375 NS
                                        × × × lt.PWM 3.375 NS
Mirza et al.38 10.31 27 13 18 NA DSM-IV 2.63 No No 26.8 NA NA 1.5 Undone NA Single Absolute 272 2300 × × lt.thalamus 0.8 NS
                                        × × rt.thalamus 0.8 NS
Mohamed et al.28 36.7 10 4 10 4 DSM-IV 23.5 No Medicated 14.3 NA NA 1.5 Undone NA Single Cre ratio 280 2650 × × × lt.thalamus 1.1 NS
                                        × × × rt.thalamus 1.1 NAA↓
                                        × × × lt.basal ganglia 1.1 NS
                                        × × × rt. basal ganglia 1.1 NS
Ohara et al.35 24.5 12 10 12 10 DSM-IV 5.6 No Medicated 29.5 NA NA 1.5 Undone PROBE Single Cre ratio 40 1500 × × × lt.lenticular nucleus 8 NS
                                        × × × rt.lenticular nucleus 8 NS
Rosenberg et al.23 11.39 20 9 14 5 DSM-IV 3.87 Two: anxiety No 25.8 NA NA 1.5 Undone PRESS Single Absolute 272 2300 ACC 3 NS
Rosenberg et al. 37 11.19 11 4 11 4 DSM-IV 2.56 Yes: anxiety No 26.55 NA NA 1.5 Undone PRESS Single Absolute 272 2300 × × lt.medial thalamus NA NS
                                        × × rt.medial thalamus NA NS
                                        × × lt.lateral thalamus NA NS
                                        × × rt.lateral thalamus NA NS
Rosenberg et al.36 11 11 4 11 4 K-SADS-PLc 1.2 Yes: anxiety No 30.36 15.27 15.09 1.5 Undone PRESS Single Absolute 272 2300 lt.caudate 0.7 NS
                                        Occipital gray matter 8 NS
Scherk et al.40 NA 17 NA 16 NA DSM-IV NA No Medicated NA NA NA 1.5 Undone NA Single Cre ratio 30 1500 × DLPFC 3.5 NS
                                        × PMFC 3.6 NS
                                        × Putamen 3.3 NS
Starck et al.41 32.6 9 6 15 11 DSM-IV 19.4 Yes: depression Medicated 22.9 11.9 11 1.5 Undone PRESS Single Absolute 30 2000 rt.caudate nucleus 1.5 NA
                                        Anterior cingulate gyrus 3.6 NA
                                        OC 4 NA
Sumitani et al.27 29.99 20 13 26 10 DSM-IV NA NA Medicated 23.79 NA NA 1.5 Done STEAM Single Absolute 18 5000 × × ACC 4.335 NAA↓
                                        × × lt.basal ganglia 4.335 NS
                                        × × lt.FL 4.335 NS
Whiteside et al.39 41.2 15 9 15 9 DSM-IV 23.09 Yes: depression Medicated 24.13 11.73 12.4 1.5 Undone PROBE Single Cre ratio 35 2000 × lt.head of caudate 4 NS
                                        × rt.head of caudate 4 NS
                                        × lt.OFWM 4 NS
                                        × rt.OFWM 4 NAA↓
Yucel et al.31 34.4 20 10 26 13 DSM-IV 13.4 NA No/stable 19.55 9.35 10.2 3 Done PRESS Single Absolute 30 3000 rt.dACC 6.5 NS
                                        rt.rACC 6.5 NS
                                        lt.dACC 6.5 NS
                                        lt.rACC 6.5 NS

Abbreviations: ACC, anterior cingulate cortex; AHC, amygdala hippocampus complex; bl., bilateral; Cre,creatine; dAC, dorsal anterior cingulate; dACC, dorsal anterior cingulate cortex; DLPFC, dorsolateral prefrontal cortex; FL, frontal lobe; FWM, frontal white matter; HC, healthy control; lt., left; MPFC, medial prefrontal cortex; MRS, magnetic resonance spectroscopy; MTL, medial temporal lobe; NA, not applicable; NAA, N-acetylaspartate; NHC, non-healthy control; NS, nonsignificant; OC, occipital cortex; OCD, obsessive-compulsive disorder; OFA, orbitofrontal area; OFWM, orbitofrontal white matter; PC, parietal cortex; PMFC, posterior frontal cortex; PWM, parietal white matter; PL, parietal lobe; rACC, rostal anterior cingulate cortex; rt., right; TE, echo time; TR, repetition time; VOI, volume of interest.

a

Number.

b

Yale–Brown Obsessive Compulsive Scale.

c

The schedule for affective disorders abd schizophrenia for school-age children—present and lifetime versions.