Skip to main content
. Author manuscript; available in PMC: 2013 Nov 1.
Published in final edited form as: Cognition. 2012 Aug 9;125(2):219–232. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2012.07.003

Table 5.

Production data for collections of objects; question are “How many X?”a

Trial Quantity Results
1 7 mixed treats Alex says “sih-none”
2 6 mixed treats (One taken away from set 1) Alex says “sih-sih”
3 8 mixed treats (Two are added to set 2) Alex says “sih-none”, self-corrects to “eight”
4 7 mixed beans Alex says “sih-none”
5 7 small beans Alex says “sih-none”
6 8 mixed treats Alex says “eight”
7 7 1” blocks Alex says “eight”
8 8 1” blocks (One added to set 7) Alex says “eight”
9 6 1” blocks (Two removed from set 8) Alex says “sih-sih”
10 7 mixed keys Alex says “sih-sih”
11 6 mixed keys (One is removed from set 10) Alex says “sih-sih”
12 7 mixed keys (One is added to set 11) Alex says “sih-none”
13 8 mixed corks Alex says “eight”
14 7 mixed wools Alex says “sih-none”
15 8 mixed sticks Alex says “eight”
16 7 mixed sticks (One item removed from trial 15 set) Alex says “sih-none”
17 8 mixed wheats Alex says “eight”
18 7 mixed wheats (One item removed from trial 17 set) Alex says “eight”
19 7 mixed wheats (One item added and immediately removed), Alex says “sih-none”
20 7 mixed treats Alex says “sih-sih”
21 7 mixed treats (One item removed and immediately added to set 20) Alex says “sih-none”
22 8 mixed wheats Alex says “sih-none”
23 8 mixed wheats (One item removed and immediately added to set 22) Alex says “eight”
24 8 mixed beans Alex says “sih-sih’”
25 8 mixed beans (Two removed and immediately added to set 24) Alex says “eight”
26 7 mixed spools 7 orange spool, one blue spool, Alex asked “How many orange spool?”; he says “sih-none”
27 8 mixed hearts Alex says “eight”
28 7 mixed hearts Alex says “eight”
29 7 mixed hearts (One item removed and immediately added to set 28) Alex says “sih-none”
30 8 mixed beans Alex says “eight”
31 8 1” blocks Alex says “eight”
32 8 mixed treats Alex says “eight”
33 7 1” blocks Alex says “sih-none”
a

“Mixed” stimuli were of varying sizes within sets, randomized across sets. Only the 1” blocks and the small beans were sets that consisted of a single sized stimulus.