Table 1.
Research Study | PEDro Score | Study Design | Participants, n | Inclusion Criteria | Measurement Technique | Joint Laxity Measures |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Hubbard et al17 | 6 | Quasiexperimental (intact group), within subject | 51 unilateral FAI | Respond yes to select items on questionnaire | Instrumented ankle arthrometer and stress radiography with a Telos device | Total anteroposterior displacement, total internal-external rotation (abduction-adduction), anterior laxity, talar tilt laxity (stress radiography) |
Hubbard et al19 | 6 | Case control, between subject | 30 unilateral CAI, 30 controls | Respond yes to select items on questionnaire | Instrumented arthrometer | Anterior, posterior, inversion, and eversion laxity |
Hubbard15 | 6 | Case control, between subject | 16 unilateral CAI, 16 controls | Respond yes to select items on questionnaire; personal interview | Instrumented arthrometer | Anterior, posterior, inversion, and eversion laxity |
Lentell et al24 | 5 | Quasiexperimental (intact group), within subject | 34 unilateral CAI | Screened for unilateral CAI that has plateaued | Stress radiography with manual stress test | Inversion laxity via talar tilt |
Louwerens et al25 | 4 | Case control, between subject | 22 bilateral CAI, 11 unilateral CAI, 10 controls | Frequent inversion trauma and sensations of giving way | Stress radiography with custom mechanical device | Talocrural tilt and subtalar tilt |
Lui et al26 | 5 | Quasiexperimental (intact group), within subject | 15 unilateral CAI | > 2 episodes of severe unilateral sprain within 10 yrs of study | Instrumented ankle arthrometer | Anterior and inversion laxity |
van Hellemondt et al36 | 4 | Quasiexperimental (intact group), within subject | 15 unilateral CAI | Frequent inversion trauma and sensations of giving way | Stress radiography with a Telos device | Talocrural tilt and subtalar tilt |
Yamamoto et al38 | 4 | Case control, between subject | 23 unilateral CAI, 80 controls | None provided | Stress radiography with a Telos device | Talocrural tilt and subtalar tilt |
CAI, chronic ankle instability; FAI, functional ankle instability.