Skip to main content
. 2012 Aug 27;109(37):14824–14829. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1203179109

Fig. 2.

Fig. 2.

Experimental setup. Chimpanzees could occupy three cages designated as “victim,” “thief,” or “actor.” In all conditions, food (circles) had to be manipulated to drop out of a clear box onto a sliding tray (light gray). A rope, if available, could be used to pull the tray from the victim’s cage toward the thief’s cage. Another rope, as well as a large button (not shown) could be used to release a trapdoor (dark gray) underneath the tray, causing the tray and the food to fall into a box, out of the chimpanzees’ reach and sight. The four third-party conditions in which a punisher had no access to food were (A) third-party theft (thief could pull food tray away from victim), (B) third-party unfair (experimenter moved food tray away from victim and toward thief), (C) third-party loss (experimenter moved food tray from victim to empty cage), and (D) third-party no-victim (thief could pull food tray away from empty victim’s cage). The second-party conditions in which the victim could enter the actor’s cage were (E) second-party theft (thief could pull food tray away from the actor) and (F) second-party loss (experimenter moved food tray away from actor to the empty thief’s cage).