Skip to main content
. 2012 Jul 24;16(5):1337–1346. doi: 10.1007/s00784-012-0783-4

Table 1.

Overview of studies having assessed dental anxiety and dental pain between the ART and the traditional treatment approach

Reference Comparison Age Operator background Variable measured Conclusion
[19] ART vs rotary instruments 6-year-old children Dental students and dentists Discomfort: ART caused less discomfort
-Heart rate and modified Venham index (observations)
[20] ART vs rotary instruments 6–16 years old Dentists Pain: ART caused less pain
-Questions: did you feel any pain during treatment?
[21] ART vs rotary instruments 4–7 years old Pedodontist specialist Pain: ART caused less pain
-Wong–Baker FACES Pain Rating Scale
[22] ART vs rotary instruments vs ultraconservative treatment 6–7 years old Pedodontist specialist Pain: -No difference in levels of pain among treatments
-Wong–Baker FACES Pain Rating Scale -Local anaesthesia was more frequent given in the rotary instrument group
[23] -ART vs rotary instruments 6–7 years old Pedodontist specialist Anxiety: No difference in levels of anxiety between treatments
-ART vs ART with Carisolv -Venham Picture Test
           
[24] ART vs rotary instruments Children and adults Dentists and dental therapists Anxiety: Both children and adults treated with the ART were less dental-anxious
-Children's fear survey schedule
-Corah's dental anxiety scale
[25] ART vs rotary instruments vs ultraconservative treatment 6–7 years old Pedodontist specialist Anxiety: No difference in levels of anxiety among treatments
-Facial Image Scale