Skip to main content
. 2012 Sep 24;7(9):e45882. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0045882

Table 1. Characteristics of the studies included in the meta-analysis.

Study Year Ethnicity Case Control No. of case/control Genotyping method Age of case/control BMI of case/control
Kwak [28] 2012 Korean OGTT confirmed Normal fasting glucose 1399/2025 Affymetrix array, TaqMan 32.1/62.5 24.2/24.4
Kim [29] 2011 Korean OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 908/966 TaqMan 33.2/32.2 23.3/21.4
Deng [30] 2011 Chinese GDM patients Non-diabetic participants 87/91 Sequencing 31.8/29.7 23.6/21.5
Heude [31] 2011 French OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 109/1571 TaqMan NA/NA NA/NA
Wang [32] 2011 Chinese OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 705/1029 TaqMan 32.0/30.0 21.7/21.5
Pappa [33] 2011 Greek GDM per IGDW criteria Normal glucose tolerant 148/107 RFLP 32.5/26.7 26.0/24.3
Papadopoulou [34] 2011 Swede OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 803/1110 TaqMan NA/NA NA/NA
Shin [35] 2010 Korean OGTT confirmed Healthy 930/628 TaqMan 33.2/NA 23.3/NA
Cheng [36] 2010 Chinese OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 55/173 RFLP 27.0/29.6 NA/NA
Kwak [37] 2010 Korean OGTT confirmed Normal fasting glucose 869/632 TaqMan 27.9/64.7 23.1/23.3
Santos [38] 2010 Euro-Brazilian GDM per ADA criteria Healthy 150/600 RFLP 31.7/24.9 33.5/24.8
Zhou [39] 2009 Chinese OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 520/916 RFLP 32.5/30.7 21.4/21.4
Cho [40] 2009 Korean OGTT confirmed Normal fasting glucose 868/632 TaqMan 32.0/64.7 23.1/23.3
Zhu [41] 2009 Chinese GDM patients Non-diabetic participants 179/180 RFLP 28.1/27.4 24.6/23.4
Lauenborg [14] 2008 Dane OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 276/2383 TaqMan 43.1/45.2 28.9/25.0
Shaat [42] 2007 Swede OGTT confirmed Non-diabetic participants 637/1232 TaqMan 32.3/30.5 NA/NA
Tok [43] 2006 Turkish OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 100/62 RFLP 33.5/31.6 26.6/23.0
Shaat [44] 2006 Swede OGTT confirmed Non-diabetic participants 641/1229 RFLP NA/NA NA/NA
Shaat [45] 2005 Swede OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 588/1180 TaqMan 32.2/30.5 NA/NA
Shaat [46] 2004 Swede OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 500/550 RFLP 32.3/NA 30.1/NA
Chiu [47] 1994 American OGTT confirmed Non-diabetic participants 174/99 SSCP 28.3/22.1 33.9/22.5
Unpublished data / Chinese OGTT confirmed Normal glucose tolerant 50/50 RFLP 30.5/28.8 31.0/27.9

OGTT: Oral Glucose Tolerance Test, IGDW: International Gestational Diabetes Workshop, ADA: American Diabetes Association, NA: Not Available.