Skip to main content
. 2012 Sep 25;7(9):e44619. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0044619

Table 3. nAb titres by serum neutralizing tests (SNTs), clinical reaction indexes (CRIs) and the percentage of protection.

Group Animal number SNT titres (day) against BTV1, BTV6 or BTV8a CRIb % protectionc
21 (0 dpc) 42 (21 dpc)
BTV1 BTV6 BTV8 BTV1 BTV6 BTV8
BTVac-1 4905 80 15 15 10 20 20 0 100
4906 120 <10 15 30 10 20 0 100
4907 640 15 20 960 20 80 1 87.5
4908 3840 10 480 160 30 640 1 87.5
Mean ± SE 0.5±0.29 93.8±3.6
BTVac-6d 4901 <10 640 80 <10 160 40 0 100
4902 10 640 320 <10 80 120 1 87.5
4903 20 160 <10 <10 160 40 0 100
4904 10 320 40 <10 40 40 1 87.5
Mean ± SE 0.5±0.29 93.8±3.6
BTVac-8 4909 <10 <10 480 <10 20 80 3 62.5
4910 <10 <10 480 <10 10 480 2 75
4911 <10 <10 640 15 20 320 0 100
4912 <10 10 2560 <10 30 2560 0 100
Mean ± SE 1.25±0.75 84.4±9.4
CombiVace 4913 1280 15 160 1280 640 480 2 75
4914 20 <10 960 320 10 1280 3 62.5
4915 20 15 640 480 320 160 2 75
4916 30 <10 5120 480 <10 1280 0 100
Mean ± SE 1.75±0.63 78.1±7.9
control 4917 <10 <10 <10 <10 15 1280 6 NA
4918 10 10 15 160 10 3840 9 NA
4919 <10 <10 <10 <10 <10 2560 5 NA
4920 <10 <10 <10 <10 <10 960 12 NA
Mean ± SE 8.0±1.58

a. The respective serum neutralization titres were determined against 30–300 TCID50 of the indicated BTVs and expressed as the dilution of serum giving a 50% neutralisation endpoint.

b. The clinical reaction index (CRI) was determined according to Huismans et al [24]. See also materials and methods.

c. The percentage of protection was determined as 100-RR, in which RR is the CRI of each sheep expressed as a percentage of that of the average control.

d. BTVac-6 was previously named rgBTV6 [17].

e. CombiVac is a combination of BTVac-1, BTVac-6, BTVac-8.