Skip to main content
. 2012 Oct 15;7(10):e47309. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0047309

Table 1. Toxicity of various insecticides to laboratory susceptible (Lab-PK) and field collected populations of H. armigera.

Population Insecticides LC50 (95% FL)(µg/ml) Slope ± SE RR1 DR2 n3
Susceptible Cry1Ac 0.58 (0.28–1.20) 1.07±0.16 240
Susceptible Chlorpyrifos 0.46 (0.18–0.96) 1.03±0.17 240
Susceptible Profenofos 0.50 (0.20–1.03) 1.06±0.17 240
Susceptible Cypermethrin 0.26 (0.12–0.50) 1.20±0.17 240
Susceptible Spinosad 1.45 (0.69–2.79) 1.13±0.18 240
Susceptible Indoxacarb 0.90 (0.48–1.71) 1.27±0.17 240
Susceptible Abamectin 0.23 (0.08–0.54) 0.85±0.14 240
Susceptible Deltamethrin 0.42 (0.17–0.78) 1.27±0.22 240
Field Cry1Ac 335.7 (244.2–477.6) 2.43±0.31 579 240
Field Chlorpyrifos 148.7 (106.3–217.0) 2.29±0.27 323 240
Field Profenofos 557.4 (420.3–734.5) 3.20±0.46 1115 240
Field Cypermethrin 506.8 (387.7–680.7) 3.28±0.44 1949 240
Field Spinosad 284.7 (180.0–484.7) 1.74±0.30 196 240
Field Indoxacarb 341.2 (260.8–459.7) 3.08±0.34 379 240
Field Abamectin 159.2 (121.3–208.8) 3.15±0.53 692 240
Field Deltamethrin 16.02 (12.74–20.32) 3.49±0.45 38 240
Field-UNSEL (G6)4 Cry1Ac 19.65 (11.56–33.04) 1.50±0.22 34 −0.21 240
Field-UNSEL (G6) Chlorpyrifos 11.75 (7.96–17.83) 2.04±0.25 26 −0.18 240
Field-UNSEL (G6) Profenofos 18.48 (12.30–27.83) 2.05±0.25 37 −0.25 240
Field-UNSEL (G6) Cypermethrin 20.07 (12.71–31.48) 1.83±0.24 77 −0.23 240
Field-UNSEL (G6) Spinosad 9.22 (5.76–14.81) 1.66±0.23 6 −0.25 240
Field-UNSEL (G6) Indoxacarb 8.07 (4.04–14.37) 1.29±0.20 9 −0.27 240
Field-UNSEL (G6) Abamectin 9.27 (5.88–14.79) 1.77±0.24 40 −0.21 240
Field-UNSEL (G6) Deltamethrin 1.76 (1.14–2.61) 1.90±0.30 4 −0.16 240
1

Resistance ratio = LC50 of field and unselected (UNSEL) population÷LC50 of Lab-PK.

2

Decline in resistance = Log10 (initial LC50–final LC50)÷number of generation the population of unexposed to toxicant.

3

The number of larvae exposed to toxins in bioassays including controls.

4

Generations.