Table 8.
Factor | x/ya | Evidence | Outcomesb | References | Confounders |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Maternal age | 11/23 | Conflicting | DP: younger | [28, 80, 82, 83] | Parity [59, 76] |
DP: older | [59, 76d] | ||||
DP: no effect | [31, 35,45, 48, 60, 61, 76e, 78, 107] | ||||
AP: younger | [13f, 53, 81, 95, 109] | ||||
AP: no effect | [13g, 17, 96] | ||||
Number of pregnancies | 11/21 | Conflicting | DP: higher | [23, 28, 45, 59, 76d, 82] | – |
DP: no effect | [7, 31, 35, 48, 61, 76e, 78, 80, 107] | ||||
AP: lower | [53, 108] | ||||
AP: higher | [17, 81, 109] | ||||
AP: no effect | [96] | ||||
Maternal height | 1/8 | Weak | DP: no effect | [35, 48, 59, 61, 78, 82, 99] | Maternal weight [13] |
AP: shorter | [13]g | ||||
Maternal weight | 5/16 | Weak | DP: heavier | [23, 28, 45, 78h] | – |
DP: no effect | [31, 35, 48, 59, 61, 78, 82, 99] | ||||
AP: heavier | [13]f, g | ||||
AP: no effect | [17, 95, 96] | ||||
Foetal weight | 2/10 | Weak | DP: heavier | [28i, 99] | – |
DP: no effect | [31, 35, 59, 61, 83, 95] | ||||
AP: no effect | [13g, 95, 96] | ||||
Maternal ethnicity | 3/5 | Conflicting | DP: Caucasian | [31] | – |
DP: Sephardic | [78] | ||||
AP: Asian | [53] | ||||
AP: no effect | [95, 96] | ||||
Maternal bone density | 0/1 | No | DP: no effect | [10] | – |
Oral contraceptives | 1/4 | Weak | DP: no effect | [7, 11, 82] | – |
AP: short term use | [11] | ||||
Smoking | 2/5 | Weak | DP: yes | [7, 28] | Strenuous work [7] |
DP: no effect | [45, 48, 99] | ||||
Strenuous work | 8/12 | Strong | DP: yes | [7, 19, 28, 35, 82] | – |
DP: no effect | [15, 48] | ||||
AP: yes | [15, 53, 81] | ||||
AP: no effect | [19, 109] | ||||
Previous low back pain (in four of the studies related to menstruation) | 12/18 | Strong | DP: yes | [35, 45j, 48, 61, 78, 80, 82] | – |
DP: no effect | [7, 11, 45k, 61, 107] | ||||
AP: yes | [11, 13, 81, 96, 109] | ||||
AP: no effect | [17] | ||||
Previous lumbopelvic pain during or after pregnancy | 11/12 | Strong | DP: yes | [7, 11, 15, 23, 45j, 48, 78, 83] | – |
DP: no effect | [45k] | ||||
AP: yes | [11, 15, 81] | ||||
Previous abortion | 0/2 | No | DP: no effect | [35, 78] | – |
Epidural anaesthesia | 2/11 | Weak | DPc: no effect | [78] | – |
AP: yes | [53, 95] | ||||
AP: no effect | [13g, 17, 43, 51, 52, 69, 96, 108] | ||||
Prolonged second stage of labour | 1/5 | Weak | AP: yes | [53] | Traumatic labour [63] |
AP: no effect | [13, 17, 95, 96] |
ax/y: x out of the y relevant studies revealed an association
bTerms such as “older” identify the risk factor in question. Note that we focused on significance: an “effect” implies that a significant relationship was found, “no effect” that no significant relationship was found
cRefers to subsequent pregnancy
dFor the first and second pregnancies
eFor the second pregnancy only
fIncluding cases where “low back pain” had been present before or during pregnancy
gExcluding such cases (cf., footnote f)
hFor nulliparous women
iA very small partial regression: r=0.0001
jFor the continuation of pain that already existed
kFor new-onset pain