Table 2.
Characteristics of clinical studies
Study | n | Outcome | Method | Conclusion | Level of evidence |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Cottom et al. [7] |
50 25 Tightrope 25 screw |
AOFAS, SF12 | Single tightrope/double tightrope versus screw fixation | AOFAS and SF12 no significant difference between screw and tightrope, 6 months postoperatively | II |
Thornes et al. [38] | 32 16 screw 16 flexible fixation | AOFAS | 4 cortices syndesmotic screw fixation versus suture-button fixation | AOFAS was significantly better in the suture-button group after 3 months and 1 year | III |
Cottom et al. [6] | 25 | AOFAS, SF 12 | Single tightrope/double tightrope | Method quick to perform. No complications, early weight-bearing, early return to daily living, sports and work | IV |
Willmott et al. [42] | 6 | Radiological evaluation | 5 single and one double tightrope | 2/6 removed. One because tender swelling over button | IV |
Thornes et al. [38] | 12 | AOFAS | Single tightrope fixation | No major complications, AOFAS mean 87 at FU at least 6 months, 8/8 returned to work in 3–16 week. Mean dorsiflexion 4.3 beyond neutral versus 8.7 contralateral | IV |
de Groot et al. [8] | 24 | AOFAS | Single/double/triple tightrope |
AOFAS 94 mean at last FU. (20 months) No major complications. 6 devices removed. 2× suture-button with subsidence Despite this no worse functional outcome |
IV |