Skip to main content
. 2012 Apr 24;7:37. doi: 10.1186/1748-5908-7-37

Table 1.

Comparison of the refined framework, closed sort task, and open sort task groupings

Refined framework domain name and constructs (* = new domain) Closed Sort Task construct groups (constructs achieving p < .05 a ; in order of confidence rating high – low) Open Sort Task construct clusters (constructs in order of s(i) values decreasing;italics= constructs with silhouette value < .25)
1. Knowledge
 
 
Knowledge (including knowledge of condition /scientific rationale)
Knowledge (including knowledge of condition /scientific rationale)
-No cluster representing Knowledge-
Procedural knowledge
Procedural knowledge
 
Knowledge of task environment
Knowledge of task environment
 
2. Skills
 
 
Skills
Skills
Competence
Skills development
Skills development
Skills
Competence
Competence
Skill assessment
Ability
Ability
Ability
Interpersonal skills
Interpersonal skills
Interpersonal skills
Practice
Practice
Skills development
Skill assessment
Skill assessment
Procedural knowledge
3. Social/ Professional Role and Identity
 
 
Professional identity
Professional identity
Organisational development
Professional role
Professional role
Organisational culture / climate
Social identity
Social identity
Management commitment
Identity
Identity
Professional role
Professional boundaries
Professional boundaries
Crew resource management
Professional confidence
Professional confidence
Leadership
Group identity
Leadership
Change management
Leadership
Group identity
Professional boundaries
Organisational commitment
Organisational commitment
Organisational commitment
 
 
Supervision
 
 
Professional identity
 
 
Project management
 
 
Champions / To champion
 
 
Team working
 
 
Power
 
 
Hierarchy
4. Beliefs about Capabilities
 
 
Self-confidence
Self-confidence
Self-efficacy
Perceived competence
Perceived competence
Perceived competence
Self-efficacy
Self-efficacy
Self-confidence
Perceived behavioural control
Perceived behavioural control
Perceived behavioural control
Beliefs
Self-esteem
Professional confidence
Self-esteem
Beliefs
Self-esteem
Empowerment
Empowerment
 
Professional confidence
Professional confidence
 
5. Optimism*
 
 
Optimism
 
Optimism
Pessimism
 
Pessimism
Unrealistic optimism
 
Unrealistic optimism
Identity
 
Identity
 
 
Mindsets
6. Beliefs about Consequences
 
 
Outcome expectancies
Outcome expectancies
Beliefs
Chars. of outcome expectancies b
Chars. of outcome expectancies b
Attitudes
Beliefs
Beliefs
Outcome expectancies
Anticipated regret
Anticipated regret
Chars. of outcome expectancies b
Consequents
Consequents
Illness representations
7. Reinforcement *
 
 
Rewards (proximal/distal, valued/not valued, probable/improbable)
 
Rewards (proximal/distal, valued/not valued, probable/improbable)
Incentives
 
Incentives
Punishment
 
Punishment
Consequents
 
Sanctions
Reinforcement
 
Contingencies
Contingencies
 
Reinforcement
Sanctions
 
Consequents
8. Intentions*
 
 
Stability of intentions
Goals (autonomous, controlled)
Stability of intentions
Stages of change model
Intrinsic motivation
Stages of change model
Trans. model/stages of change b
Goal target /setting
Trans. model/stages of change b
 
Distal and proximal goals
Certainty of intentions
 
Goal priority
Intention
 
Intention
Commitment
 
Stability of intentions
Intrinsic motivation
 
Certainty of intentions
Mods. of the intention-behaviour gapb
9. Goals*
 
 
Goals (distal / proximal)
 
Goal target/ setting
Goal priority
 
Goals (distal / proximal)
Goal / target setting
 
Goal priority
Goals (autonomous / controlled)
 
Goals (autonomous / controlled)
Action planning
 
Action planning
Implementation intention
 
Implementation intention
 
 
Representation of tasks
10. Memory, Attention and Decision Processes
 
 
Memory
Memory
Memory
Attention
Attention
Attention control
Attention control
Attention control
Attention
Decision making
Decision making
Decision making
Cognitive overload / tiredness
Cognitive overload / tiredness
Appraisal
 
 
Schemas
 
 
Cognitive overload / tiredness
11. Environmental Context and Resources
 
 
Environmental stressors
Environmental stressors
Conflict-comp. demands, conf. rolesb
Resources / material resources
Resources / material resources
Barriers and facilitators
Barriers and facilitators
Barriers and facilitators
Environmental stressors
Organisational culture /climate
Organisational culture climate
Knowledge of task environment
Person x environment interaction
Person x environment interaction
Person x environment interaction
Salient events / critical incidents
Salient events / critical incidents
Control of behaviour, material and social environment
 
 
Knowledge
 
 
Empowerment
 
 
Negotiation
 
 
Anticipated regret
 
 
Threat
 
 
Past behaviour
12. Social Influences
 
 
Social pressure
Social pressure
Group norms
Social norms
Social norms
Group conformity
Group conformity
Group conformity
Group identity
Social comparisons
Social comparisons
Social pressure
Group norms
Group norms
Social norms
Social support
Social support
Social support
Intergroup conflict
Intergroup conflict
Alienation
Power
Power
Social comparisons
Group identity
Group identity
Intergroup conflict
Alienation
Alienation
Social identity
Modelling
Modelling
 
13. Emotion
 
 
Anxiety
Anxiety
Anxiety
Fear
Fear
Depression
Affect
Affect
Positive / negative affect
Stress
Stress
Stress
Depression
Depression
Fear
Positive / negative affect
Positive / negative affect
Affect
Burn-out
Burn-out
Burn-out
14. Behavioural Regulation
 
 
Self-monitoring
Self monitoring
Learning
Breaking habit
Breaking habit
Review
Action planning
Action planning
Breaking habit
 
Direct experience
 
 
Self-monitoring
    Evaluation

Key: a = after applying Hochberg’s correction for multiple comparisons within each domain, b - Chars. of outcome expect. = Characteristics of outcome expectancies; Conflict-comp. demands, conf. roles = Conflict - competing demands, conflicting roles; Mods. of the intention-behaviour gap = Moderators of the intention-behaviour gap; Trans. model/stages of change = Transtheoretical model and stages of change.