Skip to main content
. 2012 Nov 1;7(11):e48519. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0048519

Table 1. Disease criteria and standardized part-worth utility values (β) for disease criteria levels by country.

Disease criteria1 and corresponding levels Canada US t 4
MUV 2 SD 3 MUV 2 SD 3
Case-fatality in humans
No deaths or deaths are rarely reported −68.97 30.90 −89.60 29.97 13.30***
Case-fatality is low (6%) −53.69 21.49 −45.59 20.23 7.62***
Case-fatality is moderate (35%) 20.59 22.78 22.02 26.43 1.14
Case-fatality is high (80%) 102.07 32.25 113.17 28.60 7.14***
Incidence of the disease in the Canadian/US human population in the last five years
0 cases −72.23 27.16 −85.10 31.02 8.66***
5 cases −39.50 23.14 −37.25 22.11 1.95
100 cases 17.79 18.97 23.00 16.45 5.76***
10,000 cases 93.94 37.71 99.34 33.69 2.96**
Case-fatality in animals
No deaths or deaths are rarely reported −61.85 27.48 −49.87 19.72 9.81***
Case-fatality is low (6%) −27.10 17.61 −33.58 15.82 7.59***
Case-fatality is moderate (35%) 10.72 23.28 8.52 19.12 2.02*
Case-fatality is high (80%) 78.23 29.56 74.93 22.65 2.46*
Incidence of the disease in the Canadian/US animal population in the last five years
0 cases −57.44 30.36 −63.48 21.73 4.48***
5 cases −27.41 21.62 −33.30 22.75 5.20***
100 cases 11.75 21.22 17.59 20.46 5.50***
10,000 cases 73.11 34.79 79.18 24.75 3.94***
Severity of illness in humans
No clinical symptoms or illness that is not noticeable −54.46 22.61 −54.64 26.54 0.15
Mild clinical symptoms (time off work, some medical assistance and personal care at home) −28.07 23.11 −26.93 14.68 1.16
Moderate clinical symptoms (urgent medical care and hospital admission) 8.29 19.19 8.28 18.40 0.02
Severe clinical symptoms (failure of major organ system/s necessitating long-term hospital admission) 74.24 29.72 73.29 29.71 0.63
Disease trend in Canada/US in the last five years in humans
Decline over the last five years −58.29 24.03 −58.83 18.49 0.50
Stable over the last five years −34.30 20.40 −26.89 18.53 7.45***
Increase over the last five years 29.29 19.26 26.43 17.85 3.02**
New emerging disease, rapid increase over the last five years 63.30 26.80 59.29 24.37 3.07**
Transmission potential between humans
No transmission between humans −52.93 22.50 −47.07 18.19 5.61***
Low transmission between humans −30.86 19.95 −34.42 21.40 3.37**
Moderate transmission between humans 12.71 17.35 17.57 18.87 5.28***
High transmission between humans 71.08 18.90 63.92 21.28 6.98***
1

Presented in order of importance to Canadian participants.

2

Mean part-worth utility values (β) across respondents.

3

Standard deviation of mean part-worth utility values (β) across respondents.

4

t-statistic; d.f. = 1,537.

*

p<0.05,

**

p<0.01,

***

p<0.001.

Adjusted for unequal variance using the Welch t-test; Satterthwaite’s d.f. = 1,282.61 to 1531.22.