Skip to main content
. 2012 Nov 1;7(11):e48519. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0048519

Table 2. Disease criteria and standardized part-worth utility values (β) for disease criteria levels by country.

Disease criteria1 and corresponding levels Canada US t 4
MUV 2 SD 3 MUV 2 SD 3
Duration of illness in humans
No illness observed or only a few days of illness −47.58 22.40 −46.58 31.05 0.72
Short-term illness (weeks) −26.00 23.78 −22.08 16.16 3.78***
Medium-term illness (months) 6.26 21.34 3.24 23.55 2.64**
Chronic illness (years) or illness with permanent deficits 67.32 30.94 65.42 30.09 1.23
Transmission potential from animals to humans
No transmission from animals to humans −38.81 18.86 −41.89 17.39 3.33**
Low transmission from animals to humans −28.33 18.40 −33.07 17.43 5.19***
Moderate transmission from animals to humans 5.23 17.15 13.03 16.83 9.00***
High 61.91 21.12 61.93 21.09 0.02
Disease trend in Canada/US in the last five years in animals
Decline over the last five years −47.50 21.98 −48.38 21.66 0.80
Stable over the last five years −24.50 18.50 −26.24 19.01 1.82
Increase over the last five years 25.03 18.23 28.13 17.74 3.38**
New emerging disease, rapid increase over the last five years 46.97 22.54 46.49 24.71 0.40
Economic burden in humans
No cost to the health care system and individuals −35.66 26.38 −34.54 24.26 0.86
Low cost ($100 per sick individual) −14.78 22.27 −22.16 18.03 7.14***
Moderate cost ($1,000 per sick individual) 6.50 16.63 8.61 16.44 2.50*
High cost ($10,000 per sick individual) 43.94 36.21 48.10 31.32 2.41*
Transmission potential from humans to animals
No transmission from humans to animals −26.88 17.37 −27.19 21.58 0.31
Low transmission from humans to animals −25.98 18.96 −27.03 19.44 1.07
Moderate transmission from humans to animals 6.74 15.47 13.44 15.48 8.49***
High transmission from humans to animals 46.13 26.65 40.79 22.95 4.21***
Duration of illness in animals
No illness observed or only a few days of illness −28.32 19.05 −33.47 18.99 5.31***
Short-term illness (weeks) −9.97 20.26 −10.85 17.58 0.91
Medium-term illness (months) 1.21 18.71 6.68 17.37 5.93***
Chronic illness (years) or illness with permanent deficits 37.08 24.28 37.63 22.53 0.47
Transmission potential between animals
No transmission between animals −27.27 21.02 −23.24 18.21 4.01***
Low transmission between animals −13.53 15.78 −18.35 13.60 6.42***
Moderate transmission between animals 4.76 15.33 3.52 18.29 1.45
High transmission between animals 36.03 18.62 38.08 18.44 2.17*
1

Presented in order of importance to Canadian participants.

2

Mean part-worth utility values (β) across respondents.

3

Standard deviation of mean part-worth utility values (β) across respondents.

4

t-statistic; d.f. = 1,537.

*

p<0.05,

**

p<0.01,

***

p<0.001.

Adjusted for unequal variance using the Welch t-test; Satterthwaite’s d.f. = 1,282.61 to 1531.22.