Table 3.
Overview of literature
| Author and year | Mean age |
Knees/ patients |
Follow-up (year) |
Technique | Score | Results a | Redislocation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vahasarja 1995 | 13 | 57/48 | 4.2 | MIxed b | Insall | E 20, G 20, F 11, P 6 | 13 |
| Schneider et al. 1997 | 16 | ?/17 | 10 | Goldwaith procedure | Bentley | recurrent group: E 20%; G 20%, F 20%, P 10% habitual group: E 43%; G 28%; F 14%; P 14% |
1 |
| Zeichen et al. 1998 | 21 | ?/45c | 6.5 | prox. realignment with | Larsen, | first-time dislocation: E 3, G 10, F 2 | |
| Insall technique | Lauridsen | recurrent dislocation: E 7, G 12, F 10, P 1 | 1 | ||||
| Letts et al. 1999 | 14 | 26/22 | 2.4 | Semi-membranosus | Lysholm, | E 6, G 12, P 4 | 1 |
| tenodesis | Zarins-Rowe | ||||||
| Marsh et al. 2006 | 14 | 30/20 | 6.2 | modified Roux-Goldwaith | Insall | E 26, G 3, F 1 | 0 |
| Ali et al. 2007 | 26 | 36/35 d | 4.3 | proximal arthroscopic | Lysholm | E+G 28, F 4, P 4 | 2 |
| Joo et al. 2007 | 6 | 6/5 | 4.5 | 4 in 1 technique | Kujala | E 5, G 1 | 0 |
| Oliva et al. 2009 | 13 | ?/25 | 3.8 | 3 in 1 technique | Cincinnati, Kujala |
scores increased significantly from pre- to postoperative |
1 |
| Luhmann et al. 2011 | 14 | 27/23 | 5.1 | proximal and/or distal realignment surgery |
Tegner, Lysholm |
mean Tegner 5.4 mean Lysholm 69.3 |
2 |
a E – excellent, G – good, F – fair, and P – poor
b Mixed: lateral release with or without medial reefment and/or Roux–Goldwaith procedure
c 15 first-time dislocations + 30 recurrent dislocations
d 24 dislocations + 12 subluxations