Skip to main content
. 2012 Jun 13;12:61. doi: 10.1186/1471-244X-12-61

Table 4.

Results of meta-regression analysis

  Response (lnBR) Depression symptoms (SMD)
 
constant1
beta2
p

constant1
beta2
p

% early onset
0.34
−0.30
.564
.06
0.43
−0.63
.255
.19
baseline severity
−0.66
0.04
.160
.28
−0.89
0.05
.129
.32
diagnosis (reference dysthymia)
−0.05
 
 
.69
−0.18
 
 
.69
% chronic MD
 
1.44
.028
 
 
0.88
.252
 
% recurrent without remission
 
−1.16
.211
 
 
−0.88
.312
 
% double depression
 
0.40
.085
 
 
0.81
.111
 
mean age
1.46
−0.03
.463
.09
0.75
−0.02
.760
.01
% female
−0.55
1.13
.373
.13
−0.77
1.43
.372
.12
sessions
−0.13
0.02
.631
.03
−0.27
0.03
.560
.04
treatment duration (weeks)
0.31
−0.01
.521
.06
0.37
−0.02
.137
.19
setting outpatient (vs. inpatient)
0.39
−0.24
.348
.15
0.29
−0.20
.469
.07
type of PT (reference IPT)
0.07
 
 
.57
−0.01
 
 
.40
CBT
 
0.15
.555
 
 
0.06
.846
 
CBASP
 
0.33
.002
 
 
0.34
.028
 
BSP
 
−0.23
.365
 
 
−0.05
.807
 
type of medication SSRI (vs. others)
0.42
−0.40
≤.001
.72
0.53
−0.54
.003
.64
low risk of bias (vs. medium)
0.28
−0.12
.599
.05
0.21
−0.10
.754
.01
total N in study
0.23
−0.00
.756
.02
0.13
0.00
.980
.00
multiple regression analysis
0.33
 
 
0.79
0.38
 
 
.78
% chronic MD
 
0.51
.317
 
 
0.54
.237
 
CBASP
 
−0.66
.769
 
 
−0.01
.969
 
type of medication SSRI (vs. others)   −0.35 .021     −0.46 .035  

1 unstandardized regression constant (equals treatment effect reference category) 2 unstandardized regression weight; positive values indicate superiority of the add-on psychotherapy to medication over medication alone; lnBR = natural logarithm of Benefit Risk; SMD = Standardized Mean Difference; p = level of significance; R² = explained variance; MD = Major Depression; PT = psychotherapy; IPT = Interpersonal Psychotherapy; CBT = Cognitive Behavioural Therapy; CBASP = Cognitive Behavioural Analysis System of Psychotherapy; BSP = Brief Supportive Psychotherapy.