Table 2.
Authors and year | Country | Design | Study group (N) | Control group (N) | Diagnoses | Intervention | Target | Length of intervention | Effectiveness |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Sletten et al. [1967] | USA | Experimental, crossover | 14 | SCZ | Calorie restriction | Weight reduction | 8 weeks | Yes | |
Harmatz and Lapuc [1968] | USA | Experimental randomised | 21 | SCZ | (a) Diet versus (b) group therapy versus (c) behavioural modification | Weight reduction | 10 weeks | No (a), Yes (b, c) | |
Rotatori et al. [1980] | USA | Experimental | 7 | 7 | SMI | Counselling, tokens, self-reinforcement | Weight reduction | 14 weeks | Not significantly |
Lukoff et al. [1986] | USA | Naturalistic | 28 | SCZ | Holistic programme, including stress reduction | Physical health, cardiovascular fitness | 10 weeks | Possibly | |
Mcdougall [1992] | UK | Naturalistic | 11 | SCZ | Nutritional education | Weight reduction, eating behaviour | 8 weeks | No | |
Pelham et al. [1993] | Canada | Naturalistic | 11 | SCZ | Exercise | Physical health, cardiovascular fitness | 8 weeks | Yes | |
Merriman et al. [1995] | UK | Naturalistic | 6 | SMI | Diet, exercise, self-assertiveness training | Weight reduction | 12 weeks | Not significantly | |
Roll et al. [1998] | USA | Experimental, crossover, ABA design | 11 | SCZ, SCZA | Monetary reinforcement | Smoking cessation/reduction | 3 weeks | Yes (abstinence, reduction) | |
Aquila and Emanuel [2000] | USA | Retrospective | 32 | SCZ, SCZA | Low-fat/calorie diet, nutritional education | Weight reduction | 18 months | Yes, partially | |
Ball et al. [2001] | USA | Experimental | 11 | 11 | SMI | Weight Watchers programme | Weight reduction | 10 weeks | Yes, for men only |
Cohen et al. [2001] | USA | Retrospective chart review | 39 | Mental retardation | Calorie restriction | Weight reduction | 2 years | No | |
Umbricht et al. [2001] | Switzerland | Naturalistic | 10 | SCZ | CBT, group and individual | Weight reduction | 6 weeks | Yes | |
Feeney et al. [2003] | Ireland | Experimental | 9 | 42 | SCZ | Weight management programme | Weight reduction | 3 years | Yes |
Littrell et al. [2003] | USA | RCT | 35 | 35 | SCZ, SCZA | Psycho-education (wellbeing) versus standard care | Weight reduction | 6 months | Yes (attenuated weight gain) |
O’Keefe et al. [2003] | USA | Naturalistic, retrospective chart review | 35 | SMI | Dietician input, self-directed diet as part of the treatment plan | Weight reduction | 84 ± 21 months | Yes | |
Vreeland et al. [2003] | USA | Experimental | 31 | 15 | SCZ, SCZA | Nutritional education, exercise, motivational counselling | Weight reduction | 12 weeks | Yes |
Menza et al. [2004] | USA | Experimental | 31 | 20 | SCZ, SCZA | Nutritional education, exercise, behavioural strategies | Weight reduction | 52 weeks | Yes |
Ohlsen et al. [2004] | UK | Naturalistic | 44 | SCZ, SCZA | Weight management programme | Weight reduction | 1 year | Not significantly | |
Beebe et al. [2005] | USA | Experimental | 6 | 4 | SCZ | Walking group | Weight reduction | 16 weeks | Yes |
Brar et al. [2005] | USA | Experimental, open label, rater blinded, randomized | 34 | 37 | SCZ, SCZA | Group behavioural treatment | Weight reduction | 14 weeks | Yes |
Evans et al. [2005] | Australia | RCT | 29 | 22 | SCZ, SCZA | Individual nutritional education + OLZ versus OLZ | Weight reduction | 3 months | Yes (attenuated weight gain) |
Fogarty and Happell [2005] | Australia | Naturalistic, quantitative | 6 | SCZ | Structured exercise programme | Physical health, cardiovascular fitness | 3 months | Yes | |
Kalarchian et al. [2005] | USA | Naturalistic, chart review | 35 | SCZ | Behavioural weight control programme | Weight reduction | 12 weeks | Yes, sustained | |
McCreadie et al. [2005] | UK | RCT | 67 | 24 | SCZ | Provision of fruit and vegetables ± nutritional education | Diet | 6 months | Yes, but not sustainable |
Skrinar et al. [2005] | USA | RCT | 10 | 10 | SMI | Exercise | Weight reduction | 12 weeks | Not significantly |
Alvarez-Jimenez et al. [2006] | Spain | RCT | 28 | 33 | SMI (FE) | Early behavioural intervention + OLZ/RISP/HAL versus OLZ/RISP/HAL | Weight reduction | 3 months | Yes (attenuated weight gain) |
Baker et al. [2006] | Australia | RCT | 147 | 151 | SMI | Motivational interviewing + CBT + NR versus NR | Smoking cessation/reduction | 12 months | Yes (reduction, discontinuation), No (abstinence) |
Brown and Chan [2006] | UK | RCT | 15 | 13 | SMI | Health promoting intervention | Weight reduction | 6 weeks | Yes |
Kwon et al. [2006] | S. Korea | RCT | 33 | 15 | SCZ, SCZA | Weight management + OLZ versus OLZ | Weight reduction | 12 weeks | Yes |
McKibbin et al. [2006] | USA | RCT | 28 | 29 | SCZ, SCZA | DART versus TAU | Weight reduction | 24 weeks | Yes |
Scocco et al. [2006] | Italy | Naturalistic | 20 | SCZ, SCZA | Psycho-education at an early and late phase of OLZ treatment | Weight reduction | 24 weeks | Yes (attenuated weight gain in late intervention) | |
Weber and Wyne [2006] | USA | RCT | 8 | 9 | SCZ, SCZA | CBT versus TAU | Weight reduction | 16 weeks | Yes |
Khazaal et al. [2007] | Switzerland | RCT | 31 | 30 | SCZ, SCZA | CBT versus brief nutritional education | Weight reduction | 12 weeks | Yes |
Pendlebury et al. [2007] | UK | Naturalistic | 93 | SMI | Behavioural treatment programme | Weight reduction | 4 years | Yes (increasing dropouts) | |
Poulin et al. [2007] | Canada | Naturalistic | 59 | 51 | SCZ, SCZA | Weight control programme | Weight reduction | 18 months | Yes |
Smith et al. [2007] | UK | Naturalistic | 966 | SMI | Wellbeing support programme (6 consultations) | Weight reduction | 2 years | Yes | |
Wu et al. [2007] | Taiwan | Experimental | 28 | 25 | SCZ | Low-calorie diet, exercise + CLOZ versus CLOZ | Weight reduction | 6 months | Yes |
Chafetz et al. [2008] | USA | RCT | 90 | 109 | SMI | Wellbeing training versus TAU | Physical health | 12 months | Yes (self-reported health status) |
Forsberg et al. [2008] | Sweden | RCT | 24 | 17 | SMI | Healthy living programme versus TAU | Weight reduction | 12 months | Not significantly, yes for MetS prevalence |
Lindenmayer et al. [2009] | USA | Naturalistic | 275 | SCZ, SCZA | Structured wellbeing programme | Weight reduction | 36 weeks | Yes | |
Beebe et al. [2011] | USA | RCT | 48 | 49 | SCZ, SCZA | Motivational intervention | Physical exercise attendance | 16 weeks | Yes |
Eldridge et al. [2011] | UK | Naturalistic | 159 | SMI | Wellbeing support programme | Physical health | 9–12 months | Yes (blood pressure, BMI) |
BMI, body mass index; CBT, cognitive behavioural therapy; CLOZ, clozapine; DART, diabetes awareness rehabilitation training; FE, first episode; HAL, haloperidol; NR, nicotine replacement; OLZ, olanzapine; RCT, randomized controlled trial; RISP, risperidone; SCZ, schizophrenia; SCZA, schizoaffective disorder; SMI, serious mental illness; TAU: treatment as usual.