Skip to main content
. 2012 Nov 20;7(11):e47450. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0047450

Table 1. Comparison of bootstrap percentages of phylogenetic estimates and data set manipulations for selected taxonomic groups.a .

Edafopoda Altocrust-acea Vericrust-acea Multicrust-acea Miracrust-acea Xenocarida
phylogenetic estimates
GTR+I+G degen1 92 93 86 100 94 93
JTT 20AA 64 20 24 52 16 55
21AA 89 66 64 90 66 87
Δ +25 +46 +40 +38 +50 +32
GTR 20AA 59 16 13 37 10 39
21AA 80 58 40 74 45 70
Δ +21 +41 +27 +37 +35 +31
ECM 20AA 70 6 15 43 8 27
21AA 87 52 54 86 42 64
Δ +17 +46 +39 +43 +34 36
mimicking amino acids with nucleotides
Ser1 to Ser2 degen1 54 57 40 84 42 59
Δ −38 −36 −46 −16 −52 −34
Ser2 to Ser1 degen1 66 63 47 90 41 58
Δ −26 −30 −39 −10 −53 −35
identifying important serines
no Ser1, no Ser2 degen1 59 32 26 53 27 52
Δ −33 −61 −60 −47 −67 −41
no co-Ser1, no co-Ser2 degen1 52 51 47 75 38 68
Δ −40 −42 −39 −25 −56 −25
no co-Ser1 degen1 60 55 41 75 42 69
Δ −32 −38 −45 −25 −52 −24
no co-Ser2 degen1 59 52 53 92 33 61
Δ −33 −41 −33 −8 −61 −32
no non-co-Ser1, no non-co-Ser2 degen1 94 88 78 100 91 91
Δ +2 −5 −8 0 −3 −2
no non-co-Ser1 degen1 94 90 82 100 93 92
Δ +2 −3 −4 0 −1 −1
no non-co-Ser2 degen1 92 90 84 100 93 92
Δ 0 −3 −2 0 −1 −1
separating serine codon clusters artificially in amino acid data
co-Ser1 to Phe 20AA 94 59 59 89 65 84
Δ +29 +39 +35 +37 +49 +29
co-Ser1 to Trp 20AA 95 69 66 97 64 84
Δ +30 +49 +42 +45 +48 +29
co-Ser1 to Tyr 20AA 95 65 70 95 67 83
Δ +31 +45 +46 +43 +51 +28
co-Ser2 to Phe 20AA 94 52 56 97 78 91
Δ +30 +33 +32 +45 +62 +36
co-Ser2 to Trp 20AA 95 67 69 98 80 92
Δ +31 +47 +46 +46 +64 +37
co-Ser2 to Tyr 20AA 93 62 62 97 73 90
Δ +29 +42 +38 +45 +57 +35
a

Maximum likelihood bootstrap results of phylogenetic estimates ( = uppermost cluster of bootstrap values) for all nodes are in Table S1. Bootstrap results of manipulated matrices (mimicking amino acids with nucleotides, indentifying important serines, separating serine codon clusters artificially in amino acid data) are in Table S2. GTR+I+G degen1: Empirical nucleotide rate matrix estimated from the degen1-encoded data matrix according to a general time reversible model with rate heterogeneity estimated by a gamma function plus invariant sites. JTT 21AA & 20AA: Amino acid rate matrix of Jones, Taylor, and Thornton [12] with or without separate rate estimates for Ser1 and Ser2 (21AA and 20AA, respectively). GTR 20AA & 21AA: Empirical amino acid rate matrix estimated from the actual data according to a general time reversible model. ECM 20AA & 21AA: Amino acid rate matrix estimated from the PANDIT-based Empirical Codon Model [16]. Δ: For amino acid analyses, the difference in bootstrap percentages of the 21AA result minus the 20AA result. For nucleotide analyses, the difference in bootstrap percentages of the altered data set minus the unaltered data set (GTR+I+G). Differences >15% are bold. Ser1 to Ser2, Ser2 to Ser1: Ser1 codons (TCN) were artificially changed to Ser2 (AGY) from the degen1 data matrix, or vice versa. No Ser1, no Ser2: Ser1 and Ser2 codons were deleted (changed to NNN) from the degen1 data matrix. No (non-)co-Ser1, no (non-)co-Ser2: (Non-)ComminglingSer1 and Ser2 codons were both separately and together deleted from the degen1 data matrix. Co-Ser1 (Ser2) to Phe, Trp, Tyr: Co-Ser1 (Ser2) residues were changed to Phe, Trp, or Try residues, respectively.